The division preview series starts with the AL West. The starting point for my analysis is the 2012 WAR of the position players, the starting rotation and the closer. All WAR numbers come from FanGraphs. The Rangers and Astros open the 2012 season Sunday night.
Oakland Athletics
- Position Player WAR: 20.2
- Pitcher WAR: 9.7
- Total: 29.9
The A’s are in good shape to compete for a playoff spot. Among the 16 players represented above, there are three points with upside. Scott Sizemore did not play in the majors in 2012, but with a great career minor league OBP, he could easily add one to two WAR to the team. Yoenis Cespedes, with a major league season under his belt, should show improvement as well. Finally, a healthy Brett Anderson should do better than his 0.9 WAR in 2012. On the other hand, Josh Reddick‘s 4.5 WAR may not be repeatable. He didn’t get on base much, and a lot of his wins are based on defense.
The main players on Oakland should put them over .500. The bullpen pitched extremely well in 2012, with outstanding strikeout, walk, and home run numbers as a group. Relievers can be erratic from year to year, but if they do repeat their 2012 performance, Oakland will be in the hunt for the division, and certainly the wild card.
Texas Rangers
- Position Player WAR: 21.5
- Pitcher WAR: 13.0
- Total: 34.5
Leonys Martin could be the next big star of the AL West. Photo: Jake Roth-USA TODAY Sports
The big question for the Rangers is how much Leonys Martin will make up for the loss of Josh Hamilton. He posted a slightly negative WAR in 2012, but the various projection systems have him averaging around two WAR for 2013. That would certainly help. If Martin lives up to his potential, he can certainly replace Hamilton’s production.
The only other upside in the lineup is in the person of Nick Tepesch, scheduled to be the fifth starter for the team in lieu of injuries to the rest of the rotation. Nick posted very good walk numbers in minors and mostly kept the ball in the park. He should be a serviceable fifth starter.
Overall, however, I don’t see many numbers out of line with player expectations. My guess is that Adrian Beltre and A.J. Pierzynski will have trouble repeating their excellent 2012. I see 2012’s win total as the ceiling for this Texas team, but of course that did put them in the playoffs.
Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
- Position Player WAR: 32.6
- Pitcher WAR: 8.9
- Total: 41.5
If the main core players of the Angels each match their 2012 WAR, the team makes the playoffs. Is there a reason to think they won’t? My feeling is that among the Angels hitters, there is more downside than upside potential.
Mike Trout, for example, not only posted an MVP season, but one of the great seasons of all time. A WAR of 10 is tough to repeat. If Trout posts a seven WAR in 2013, he would still be an MVP candidate, still a superstar, but the Angels would be down three wins. Much of Josh Hamilton’s 4.1 WAR came from a hot start in 2012, but he cooled off greatly in the hot Texas summer. Even Albert Pujols is at an age where a decline is more likely than a bounce back.
That’s the nice thing about going into the season with such a high batting WAR. There’s plenty of room of a fall off. The team might even get a boost from getting rid of Vernon Wells. The Angels have a nice cushion for decline.
I’m not that impressed with the pitchers, however. After Jered Weaver and C.J. Wilson, the rotation is weak. I am slowly coming around to the notion that Joe Blanton really changed, and he’s a better hurler than he used to be, with the increase in strikeouts real. Still, this isn’t the blow batters away rotation the Angels often employ. Don’t be surprised to see a ton of 7-6 games from this team.
Seattle Mariners
- Position Player WAR: 8.6
- Pitcher WAR: 9.2
- Total: 17.8
Is there something deadly about sending a hitter to Seattle, besides the former dimensions of the park? Jesus Montero posted a -0.4 WAR in 2012 despite little action on defense. With the Yankees and in the minors he showed great strike zone judgement. He only walked 29 times in 2012, good for just a .298 OBP. Do the Mariners encourage their batters to swing too much?
Montero recovering his OBP, along with improvement from Dustin Ackley and Ryan Seager will be the key to an improved Seattle season. Michael Morse and Kendrys Morales could be complementary players, but the two combined for just 1.6 WAR in 2012. Morse in the field doesn’t really help the team. Still, the upside for the offense is four or five wins.
The rotation has some upside as well. Twenty-two year old Brandon Maurer comes aboard the rotation, his first time in the majors. He showed excellent control throughout his minor league career. The other unknown is Tom Wilhelmsen, the Bartender. He quit baseball after being suspended for smoking weed, but in two minor league seasons since returning, posted a 9.4 K per 9 IP. At age 29, he’ll be the Seattle closer. Those two might give the team another three WAR.
Even with all the upside realized, the Mariners are not ready to compete. It will be a step in the right direction, and if everything breaks well, they could finish over .500.
Houston Astros
- Position Player WAR: 6.9
- Pitcher WAR: 5.1
- Total: 12.0
I will go out on a limb and predict the Astros will win more than 60 games this season. I actually like the offense, as the Musings Marcels projections put them at the level of the Yankees and Nationals. Unfortunately for Houston, they don’t own the pitching that compares to those two teams.
Bud Norris gets the opening day start. He’ll strike out batters but also walk a few too many. It just goes down hill from there.
The front office of this team were instrumental in building the Cardinals, however. Keep your eye on the moves they make throughout the season to see where they take the team.
Predictions
Here’s my predicted probability of the teams winning the divison:
- Angels 40%
- Rangers 26%
- Athletics 24%
- Mariners 9%
- Astros 1%
I suspect a very tough race among the top three teams, but I would not be shocked if the bottom two played the role of spoilers very well.