The division preview series finishes with the NL West. The starting point for my analysis is the 2012 WAR of the position players, the starting rotation and the closer. All WAR numbers come from FanGraphs. The Giants and Dodgers go head-to-head at 4 PM EDT Monday, although the Padres play earlier in the day against the Mets.
San Francisco Giants
- Position Player WAR: 23.7
- Pitcher WAR: 12.5
- Total: 36.2
Los Angeles Dodgers
- Position Player WAR: 22.0
- Pitcher WAR: 15.7
- Total: 37.7
Arizona Diamondbacks
- Position Player WAR: 23.3
- Pitcher WAR: 14.2
- Total: 37.5
The top three teams in this division come into the season evenly matched. The Giants have upside in Brandon Belt having the first base job from day one, and Tim Lincecum recoverng from an off year. The Dodgers have already felt the injury bug, as Hanley Ramirez, Carl Crawford, and Chad Billingsley won’t start the season healthy. Arizona might have the most downside, with Aaron Hill and Martin Pardo coming off great seasons. For all the money and resources the Dodgers spent, they may only have pulled even with the last two division winners. There’s nothing wrong with that, they just need to have a little luck run their way. I get the feeling, however, that if Buster Posey is healthy, the Giants will keep winning.
San Diego Padres
- Position Player WAR: 17.3
- Pitcher WAR: 2.7
- Total: 20.0
The Padres position core isn’t bad, but it’s tough to realize the potential of this unit when so many of their players are hurt. That includes Chase Headley, the one superstar on the team.
My feeling is that there is plenty of upside to Edinson Volquez, Clayton Richard, and Eric Stults. Even with a combined five WAR increase by those three, San Diego just does not have the personnel to compete with the big three.
Colorado Rockies
- Position Player WAR: 9.2
- Pitcher WAR: 4.2
- Total: 13.4
The five pitchers in the projected starting rotation for the Rockies all have the first initial, “J”, but none of them have the same first name. That might be the most interesting thing about the group.
The offense has upside, mostly if Troy Tulowitzki is healthy and gets back to his superstar production. Along with star years from Dexter Fowler and Cargo Gonzalez, the Rockies could add eight WAR to the total above. That still doesn’t put them in the playoff hunt.
Predictions:
Here’s how I see the probabilities of each team winning the division:
- Giants 31%
- Dodgers 30%
- Diamondbacks 29%
- Padres 8%
- Rockies 2%
I really think this division is a toss up between the top three teams, but I didn’t want to cop out and not pick a winner. Putting the Giants in first is based on Tim Lincecum rebounding from his poor 2012. The Dodgers show they are willing to break the bank to win, so they may make big trades to fill any weaknesses that show up early in the season. The Diamondbacks appear to have the most downside potential. The two teams who don’t finish first have a fine chance at winning the wild card. This should be an exciting race.