Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
June 03, 2005
The Darkside of the Game

Eldon Ham's new book Larceny and Old Leather is an amusing collections of stories about how baseball players, owners and teams often bend the rules or outright break them. He covers field manipulation, gambling, curses racism, sign stealing and any other mischief that is part of the lore of the game.

The book, however, should be read more as entertainment than fact. In the second paragraph of the first chapter, Ham makes an egregious error, putting Babe Ruth's record setting 59 home runs in 1923 instead of 1921. He also repeats the story about the Black Sox name coming from the White Sox uniforms being dirty, which doesn't appear to be true. This leads me to believe the book is poorly researched.

Ham drops the ball in other areas as well. I was looking forward to the chapter titled Hal Chase: Malignant Genius. Chase is one of the darkest characters in the history of baseball. He could have been the model for Senator/Emperor Palpatine in Star Wars, down to the disfigured face. But Ham doesn't explore the character of Chase, nor the reasons for the appellation above; he just attributes it to a judge.

Ham is a good story teller, but I'd like more substance. I'd also like to know that he did more than repeat embellished stories, that he actually checked the sources. It appears that didn't happen.


Posted by David Pinto at 03:17 PM | Books | TrackBack (0)
Comments

David, This book sounds interesting, thought with it's poor research, I would fear reading it. Though I would like to read a entertaining, more accurate early history of baseball. Any advice? Thanks

Posted by: Eoin Vincent at June 3, 2005 04:04 PM

Does it have a bibliography, so we could go to better sources?

Posted by: RobertJ at June 3, 2005 04:41 PM

It does have a bibliography. Eoin, I'd try the Bill James Historical Abstract.

Posted by: David Pinto at June 3, 2005 04:51 PM

Researching flaws I can understand, but how do you slip something like a record breaking home run season past editors?

Posted by: Will at June 3, 2005 05:31 PM

Hi. I just noticed your discussion and can weigh in. My new 472-page book, Cap Anson 3: Muggsy John McGraw and the Tricksters: Baseball's Fun Age of Rule Bending, is fully endnoted and slices through previous reporting on colorful on-the-field trickery and dirty play in early baseball. The book pretty much ends with 1900, but that perhaps accounts for most of the most colorful stuff that ever supposedly took place on a big league field.

I'd be glad to answer any questions. Hope you don't mind the pitch, but I have no relationship to the person who asked about the availability of an entertaining and accurate early history.

Sincerely,
Howard W. Rosenberg

Posted by: Howard W. Rosenberg at June 19, 2005 05:49 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?