Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
October 31, 2006
Smuggling Cubans

And we're not talking about cigars:

An agent for baseball players illegally smuggled Cuban players into the United States, eventually shipping them to California in hopes that they would be signed by major league teams, federal immigration officials said Tuesday.

...

Prosecutors say Rodrigues and Dominguez traveled by boat to Cuba on July 28, 2004, and loaded 22 Cubans aboard, but were intercepted by U.S. authorities at sea. Less than a month later, on Aug. 22, 2004, authorities say the two men successfully brought 19 Cubans into the country.

According to the indictment, the defendants transported the athletes to Los Angeles by van, rented an apartment for them, provided them with food and clothing and began training them. It could not be immediately determined if any of the Cubans have been signed by major league teams.

It seems to me we should be encouraging people who want to escape from Cuba, especially if they can play at the major league level.


Posted by David Pinto at 10:30 PM | Crime | TrackBack (0)
Comments

Irrelevant, but Boston just hired former Royals' GM Allard Baird to be their new assistant general manager.

Not sure how I feel about it...anyone have any insight about the guy?

Posted by: the other josh at November 1, 2006 12:15 AM

I think this is actually a sound thing to do if you think about it, David. We do (and should) allow defectors and refugees from Cuba if they flee under their own power and make it here to U.S. territory, but it is proper to prosecute anyone who works as a smuggler of human capital, regardless of the specific circumstances. Understand that the law isn't going to make an exception in this case because the people being smuggled are baseball players (though I wouldn't mind if it did!), it's going to go after such "agents" because it would be a bad idea to encourage coyotes for all sorts of policy reasons.

Leaving aside questions of national security, or of the practical difficulty in differentiating (allowed) Cubans from other (disallowed) Latin American illegals - a smuggler could be reliably counted upon to misrepresent such things were it ever to his advantage to do so - it would likely cause misery for the poor Cuban refugees themselves. Imagine how quickly many of them would fall prey to unscrupulous or phony "agents," as often currently happens with illegals making border crossings from Mexico...a bad scene all around.

It's precisely for this reason that, while we will allow any Cuban who reaches our shores to claim asylum, we don't want to encourage third parties to commodify such emigrations. Hopefully Fidel will go to his richly-deserved death soon enough, and this will cease to be an issue.

Perhaps you were just making a wisecrack, I dunno - my sarcasm detector is notoriously weak.

Posted by: Jeff B. at November 1, 2006 01:26 AM

As is your affected writing style.

Posted by: joe at November 1, 2006 05:02 AM

Jeff B, I understand your point. However, I guess I see these people as more akin to the underground railroad, illegal, but morally correct. The difference here is these agents were out to make a profit, rather than just help people escape.

Posted by: David Pinto at November 1, 2006 07:35 AM

I work for an international healthcare staffing firm and we immigrate asian healthcare professionals from third world countries to the US, for profit. The social-work feel that comes with the work can supplement my income. But from a corporate standpoint, management doesn't care what happens to our immigrants, even though they sign 2 yr contracts with us. We take care of them to the extent we can afford to - an ethical question I'm not going to get into - but really, it's about profit. Immigrants, however, need my company's help to ensure they receive their green card, establish credit, etc, which we don't have time for. So it ends up being an unfair relationship UNLESS the staffing firm can afford to deal with the immigrant's personal & professionals needs. I'm going to assume this agent cannot afford proper treatment of exiles, in which case... is he putting these Cubans under contract?

Blah blah blah - sorry. I just wanted to share some insight on the complications being overlooked... You can't just throw a dog a bone.

How many agencies do this legally? Any? It seems absurdly lucrative...

Posted by: Cape Codder at November 1, 2006 08:21 AM

So we should encourage people to leave Cuba, but send 'em all back to Mexico. Okay.

Viva Fidel!

Posted by: John Seal at November 1, 2006 02:17 PM

That's not my position at all. My feeling is that anyone who wants to come to the US should be able to do so easily.

Posted by: David Pinto at November 1, 2006 02:21 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?