Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
May 23, 2007
Giambi Under Attack

The Daily News reports Jason Giambi failed a drug test last year for stimulants. However, they do not cite the source, so as in all things like this, take it with a grain of salt. They use this as evidence:

But Giambi himself hinted at the failed test - which was later confirmed by the Daily News - in his eye-opening interview with USA Today last week, when he said that he is "probably tested more than anyone else."

Under MLB policy, there are two reasons a player would be required to submit to additional testing: The first is a failed steroid test, but failed steroid tests are made public. The second is a failed amphetamines test, which would not be made public.

I thought that if there was suspicion of use, MLB could test more. Can someone familiar with the CBA clarify this? Once Giambi gave his apology a couple of years ago, I thought MLB would be justified in testing him all the time.

Anyway, so much for confidentiality. If you MLB wants to bring a player down, they just leak a failed amphetamine test. Nice of them to stick to their agreement. And they wonder why players won't talk to George Mitchell.


Posted by David Pinto at 08:30 AM | Cheating | TrackBack (0)
Comments

Good points, David.

But isn't it possible, maybe even likely, that the leaker wasn't from MLB, but from the Yankees organization?

MLB might want to "take Giambi down," but the Yankees have a $40-plus million commitment to the guy.

Posted by: Walt in Maryland at May 23, 2007 10:32 AM

I see the "Giambi issue" getting worse. Who again signed him to that back loaded deal? And, you mean to tell me that the Yankees had "no idea" that Giambi was taking substances that were subsequently banned from MLB? I don't have any sympathy for the Glorious Yankees.

On another note, I think that at some point here, MLB and its ESPN cronies are going to regret that they haven't marketed the game much beyond the Red Sox v. Yankees. There are so many other great stories out there and so much for us baseball fans. Instead, we're dealing with (and unable to overcome) an aging slugger who had a short window of success and wants so badly to discuss his transgressions and an aging slugger who's treated as the anti-Christ and who won't admit to anything. Too bad.

For my money, read Joe Sheehan's open article at Baseball Prospectus. That's were I'm coming from.

Thank goodness for the Internet and sites like this one that allow us fans to enjoy the game beyond what we're told to believe by former players and broadcasters.

Posted by: Kent at May 23, 2007 10:33 AM

I see the "Giambi issue" getting worse. Who again signed him to that back loaded deal? And, you mean to tell me that the Yankees had "no idea" that Giambi was taking substances that were subsequently banned from MLB? I don't have any sympathy for the Glorious Yankees.

On another note, I think that at some point here, MLB and its ESPN cronies are going to regret that they haven't marketed the game much beyond the Red Sox v. Yankees. There are so many other great stories out there and so much for us baseball fans. Instead, we're dealing with (and unable to overcome) an aging slugger who had a short window of success and wants so badly to discuss his transgressions and an aging slugger who's treated as the anti-Christ and who won't admit to anything. Too bad.

For my money, read Joe Sheehan's open article at Baseball Prospectus. That's were I'm coming from.

Thank goodness for the Internet and sites like this one that allow us fans to enjoy the game beyond what we're told to believe by former players and broadcasters.

Posted by: Kent at May 23, 2007 10:33 AM

Oops, sorry for the double post.

Posted by: Kent at May 23, 2007 10:35 AM

Walt,

From my point of view, it doesn't matter if it's the Yankees or MLB. Leaking this information threatens the drug testing agreement. If this sort of thing keeps up, at some point the union says, "You're not living up to your end of the deal, we're telling all our players to refuse testing." That would be bad for baseball.

Posted by: David Pinto at May 23, 2007 10:47 AM

And Mitchell wants access to the players' medical records. To me, that request is DOA to begin with, but these leaks (there's one about Barry too) make it worse.

Posted by: rbj at May 23, 2007 12:54 PM

I just read about Giambi over at Highbrid Nation and the writer over there really put things in perspective for me. The media has really blew the whole "performance enhancing drug" thing out of proportion. Seriously, I'm not saying its ok to use these drugs but can we please stop acting like these drugs give athletes some kind of super human advantage over thier peers.

Posted by: Evorgleb at May 23, 2007 02:16 PM

i think this put the stake in the heart of mitchell's investigation - the players can't possibly think that MLB can be trusted for one second.

Posted by: lisa gray at May 24, 2007 12:06 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?