Baseball Musings
Baseball Musings
December 30, 2008
Shifting Power

Buster Olney wonders if the power struggle between MLB and the MLBPA is shifting in favor of the owners.

Wealth might have eroded the determination to enforce Miller's core principles, however. The sport is generating billions; the players are making millions. The respectful and cooperative relationship that has developed between Michael Weiner, players' counsel, and Rob Manfred, baseball's labor guru, is often cited by peers as being as asset.

But soon enough, we will know whether the owners will look to take back some of the financial landscape ceded in past battles.

I don't think so. My favorite book from college is The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. In that book Thomas Kuhn discusses how paradigm shifts happen becuase the old, hard-line believers in the previous theory die out. That happened in baseball. With George Steinbrenner stepping down, there are no owners who operated under the old reserve clause system. (George was always cool with free agency, so it was the departure of Selig from the Brewers that really ended the line.) Today's owners never knew the joy of being able to renew players year-to-year, so they really don't think about going back to that system. They operate in the confines of an agreement that allows them to keep most players under control through their prime seasons, and sign the best and the brightest when they become available. Owners today are much more interested in taking down the rich teams than the rich players. It's the unions job to make sure that taking down the rich teams doesn't hurt the players as well.


Posted by David Pinto at 12:06 PM | Union | TrackBack (0)
Comments

yM4oWW kyzgevjjoifx, [url=http://jkofohaouklb.com/]jkofohaouklb[/url], [link=http://tkqvhiuttjmu.com/]tkqvhiuttjmu[/link], http://khnkrdukaeuj.com/

Posted by: vmizegfpprn at December 30, 2008 04:00 PM

That 'baseball is awash in cash' has been true for a few years (though Selig said in 2001 that MLB lost $232 million). The cash situation looks to be reversing. The main criminals found guilty of collusion are still very much in the game, and with the most power: Selig and Reinsdorf. Many fellow colluders are still in or around the game and will agree to whatever Selig and Reinsdorf want. Owners had to pay $280 million for collusion in 1985-88. Marvin Miller? Although he retired in 1982, owners' hatred is so deep and their characters so flawed, they went to the trouble of restructuring the Hall of Fame Veterans Committee in 2008 to assure Marvin Miller will never be elected. The $280 million collusion penalty never really left the owners' pockets as has been documented. They merely sold new MLB franchises and used the fees collected to pay their collusion fines. I believe Doug Pappas wrote a lot about the owners' feelings on who owns the game. They strongly believe it belongs 100% to them. They were ready to hire replacement workers in 1995. Most of those same people are still around and feeling just fine.

Posted by: susan mullen at December 30, 2008 08:20 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?