Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Bill James Starting Pitcher Historical Rankings

Enter morning of date, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

Rank	Pitcher	Rating
1	Pedro Martinez	623.79
2	Randy Johnson	619.12
3	Kevin Brown	552.08
4	John Smoltz	515.77
5	Mike Mussina	506.38
6	Roger Clemens	504.53
7	Greg Maddux	499.0
8	Curt Schilling	497.11
9	David Cone	496.03
10	Mike Hampton	492.74
11	Kevin Millwood	492.34
12	Orlando Hernandez	492.09
13	Jamie Moyer	490.32
14	David Wells	489.29
15	Tom Glavine	478.06
16	Al Leiter	477.26
17	Bartolo Colon	474.99
18	Chuck Finley	472.46
19	Shane Reynolds	468.89
20	Dave Burba	465.88
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
21	Rick Reed	456.72
22	Jose Lima	456.69
23	Brad Radke	455.8
24	Omar Daal	451.13
25	Denny Neagle	451.11
26	Kenny Rogers	450.49
27	Jon Lieber	450.01
28	Jose Rosado	449.86
29	Aaron Sele	449.46
30	Pedro Astacio	448.73
31	Sterling Hitchcock	446.73
32	Eric Milton	445.07
33	Pete Harnisch	443.8
34	Scott Erickson	443.23
35	Rick Helling	443.16
36	Andy Ashby	442.6
37	Dustin Hermanson	442.22
38	Andy Benes	442.2
39	Juan Guzman	439.49
40	Francisco Cordova	437.49
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
41	Hideo Nomo	435.46
42	Jason Schmidt	435.09
43	James Baldwin	433.42
44	Ismael Valdes	432.58
45	Andy Pettitte	430.29
46	Steve Trachsel	429.81
47	Woody Williams	428.73
48	Charles Nagy	427.21
49	Wilson Alvarez	426.83
50	Chan Ho Park	425.69
51	Pat Hentgen	423.3
52	Orel Hershiser	422.51
53	Todd Stottlemyre	421.44
54	Bret Saberhagen	420.77
55	Masato Yoshii	419.46
56	Darren Oliver	413.65
57	Mike Sirotka	413.15
58	Brian Moehler	410.07
59	Freddy Garcia	409.11
60	Dave Mlicki	408.98
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
61	Omar Olivares	407.34
62	Darryl Kile	406.07
63	Shawn Estes	404.03
64	Russ Ortiz	403.9
65	Jeff Fassero	402.95
66	John Burkett	399.28
67	Tim Hudson	396.65
68	Livan Hernandez	396.28
69	Pat Rapp	394.39
70	Kirk Rueter	393.81
71	Rolando Arrojo	392.72
72	Kent Bottenfield	392.4
73	Kris Benson	392.37
74	Todd Ritchie	390.5
75	Hideki Irabu	390.1
76	Mark Gardner	389.95
77	Scott Karl	389.78
78	Brett Tomko	389.74
79	Steve Woodard	388.83
80	Jeff Suppan	388.0
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
81	Darren Dreifort	387.69
82	Brian Bohanon	384.83
83	Gil Heredia	383.21
84	Jaret Wright	382.39
85	Kevin Appier	380.31
86	Javier Vazquez	377.34
87	Brian Anderson	377.3
88	Esteban Loaiza	376.53
89	Kent Mercker	376.25
90	Chris Carpenter	374.61
91	Tim Wakefield	374.19
92	Justin Thompson	373.6
93	Matt Clement	372.0
94	Steve Parris	371.35
95	Sidney Ponson	370.01
96	Ryan Dempster	369.55
97	Robert Person	369.26
98	Joe Mays	367.4
99	Kevin Tapani	366.92
100	Alex Fernandez	366.9
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
101	John Halama	365.69
102	Ken Hill	363.88
103	Paul Byrd	363.29
104	Kelvim Escobar	362.24
105	Mike Thurman	361.88
106	Armando Reynoso	361.4
107	Joey Hamilton	360.26
108	Ryan Rupe	360.25
109	Dwight Gooden	358.85
110	Jamey Wright	357.56
111	Jay Witasick	356.92
112	Terry Mulholland	356.72
113	Ron Villone	356.71
114	LaTroy Hawkins	353.02
115	Tim Belcher	352.71
116	Jim Parque	350.91
117	Chris Holt	350.72
118	Mark Portugal	349.33
119	Bobby Witt	347.64
120	Randy Wolf	347.31
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
121	Mike Oquist	343.41
122	Jose Jimenez	343.24
123	Jeff Weaver	342.91
124	Jimmy Haynes	341.53
125	Brian Meadows	341.39
126	John Thomson	337.29
127	Kyle Farnsworth	337.03
128	Jason Johnson	336.94
129	Roy Halladay	334.96
130	Dennis Springer	334.66
131	Pete Schourek	334.14
132	Gil Meche	332.65
133	Scott Elarton	332.14
134	Garrett Stephenson	331.41
135	Steve Sparks	330.11
136	Octavio Dotel	328.03
137	Joe Nathan	323.57
138	Blake Stein	322.16
139	Mike Morgan	321.81
140	Chad Ogea	319.92
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
141	Jaime Navarro	314.47
142	Jeremy Powell	313.5
143	Jason Bere	313.13
144	Esteban Yan	312.79
145	Carl Pavano	312.73
146	Rob Bell	312.19
147	Chad Durbin	312.16
148	Rick Ankiel	311.15
149	Willie Blair	310.8
150	Vladimir Nunez	310.25
151	Brad Penny	309.56
152	Jason Dickson	308.84
153	Brian Boehringer	308.65
154	Miguel Batista	308.56
155	Pat Mahomes	308.26
156	Andrew Lorraine	308.23
157	Johan Santana	308.09
158	Jarrod Washburn	306.97
159	John Snyder	306.69
160	Dave Eiland	306.21
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
161	Kip Wells	305.95
162	Kyle Peterson	305.92
163	Scott Downs	305.84
164	Cal Eldred	305.42
165	Jesus Sanchez	305.03
166	Valerio de los Santos	303.96
167	Chris Peters	303.87
168	Dan Wheeler	303.86
169	Jose Mercedes	303.35
170	Mark Clark	303.24
171	C.J. Nitkowski	303.13
172	Mac Suzuki	302.99
173	Scott Schoeneweis	301.87
174	Frank Castillo	300.54

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database

None