Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Bill James Starting Pitcher Historical Rankings

Enter morning of date, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

Rank	Pitcher	Rating
1	Randy Johnson	583.28
2	Roger Clemens	577.67
3	Pedro Martinez	576.93
4	Kevin Brown	572.26
5	Greg Maddux	551.16
6	Curt Schilling	548.04
7	John Smoltz	538.9
8	David Cone	534.18
9	David Wells	517.17
10	Tom Glavine	512.15
11	Mike Mussina	499.05
12	Jeff Fassero	486.51
13	Al Leiter	484.08
14	Todd Stottlemyre	478.87
15	Shane Reynolds	478.65
16	Denny Neagle	472.03
17	Jamie Moyer	467.46
18	Andy Pettitte	464.3
19	Darryl Kile	463.6
20	Andy Benes	461.34
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
21	Chuck Finley	461.29
22	Andy Ashby	457.57
23	Kenny Rogers	455.27
24	Dustin Hermanson	454.63
25	Ismael Valdes	451.41
26	Chan Ho Park	451.1
27	Rick Reed	450.63
28	Brad Radke	449.42
29	Bobby Jones	447.04
30	Pete Harnisch	446.95
31	Mike Hampton	446.78
32	Charles Nagy	446.53
33	Dave Burba	446.11
34	Justin Thompson	441.85
35	Steve Trachsel	441.33
36	Sterling Hitchcock	439.79
37	Scott Erickson	438.57
38	Aaron Sele	437.63
39	Francisco Cordova	436.09
40	Jason Schmidt	435.97
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
41	Brian Moehler	434.08
42	Tim Wakefield	432.61
43	Wilson Alvarez	430.21
44	Bartolo Colon	429.86
45	Orlando Hernandez	429.42
46	Orel Hershiser	428.78
47	Jose Lima	426.89
48	Tim Belcher	425.1
49	Mark Gardner	423.72
50	Carlos Perez	422.84
51	Woody Williams	421.81
52	Bret Saberhagen	421.18
53	Jon Lieber	420.47
54	Mark Clark	419.36
55	Kerry Wood	419.09
56	Brett Tomko	418.0
57	Rick Helling	416.2
58	Omar Daal	415.65
59	Rolando Arrojo	413.99
60	James Baldwin	412.46
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
61	Pedro Astacio	411.75
62	John Burkett	411.32
63	Matt Morris	410.58
64	Joey Hamilton	408.32
65	Kirk Rueter	408.23
66	Hideo Nomo	406.94
67	Juan Guzman	406.91
68	Kevin Tapani	406.48
69	Jose Rosado	406.19
70	Dave Mlicki	404.67
71	Scott Karl	403.34
72	Omar Olivares	402.98
73	Pat Hentgen	401.72
74	Shawn Estes	401.72
75	Jaret Wright	399.74
76	Darren Oliver	395.74
77	John Thomson	392.64
78	Ken Hill	392.6
79	Tony Saunders	392.55
80	Willie Blair	391.09
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
81	Livan Hernandez	388.99
82	Brian Bohanon	388.89
83	Tom Candiotti	388.79
84	Chris Carpenter	387.91
85	Dwight Gooden	384.19
86	Kevin Millwood	380.94
87	Pat Rapp	380.04
88	Mike Morgan	377.93
89	Masato Yoshii	374.56
90	Bob Tewksbury	373.58
91	Steve Avery	372.71
92	Jesus Sanchez	372.56
93	Hideki Irabu	372.2
94	Jamey Wright	371.91
95	Pete Schourek	371.78
96	Brian Anderson	370.2
97	Darren Dreifort	369.69
98	Mark Portugal	369.62
99	Steve Woodard	367.62
100	Sean Bergman	366.22
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
101	Jimmy Haynes	366.08
102	Kent Mercker	365.55
103	Mike Sirotka	364.62
104	Esteban Loaiza	362.96
105	Eric Milton	360.44
106	Chris Peters	354.96
107	Brian Meadows	352.86
108	Kent Bottenfield	352.64
109	Donovan Osborne	352.54
110	Mike Remlinger	352.12
111	Carl Pavano	351.67
112	Mike Oquist	351.47
113	John Snyder	351.43
114	Jim Parque	350.41
115	LaTroy Hawkins	349.46
116	Kelvim Escobar	348.61
117	Jeff Juden	348.53
118	Steve Sparks	348.38
119	Chad Ogea	348.12
120	Javier Vazquez	346.63
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
121	Tyler Green	346.39
122	Terry Mulholland	338.09
123	Bobby Witt	337.33
124	Jaime Navarro	335.71
125	Paul Byrd	334.16
126	Ramiro Mendoza	333.26
127	Steve Parris	332.78
128	Ken Cloude	332.36
129	Carlton Loewer	331.52
130	Kevin Appier	330.18
131	Jason Bere	329.12
132	Miguel Batista	328.95
133	Armando Reynoso	328.9
134	Sidney Ponson	328.78
135	Jimmy Key	328.6
136	Julio Santana	328.56
137	Bryan Rekar	328.49
138	Russ Ortiz	327.85
139	Bobby Jones	327.02
140	Seth Greisinger	326.35
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
141	Danny Darwin	324.55
142	Gil Heredia	323.68
143	Jeff Weaver	323.02
144	Freddy Garcia	322.68
145	Amaury Telemaco	322.12
146	Brad Woodall	319.72
147	Chris Brock	319.62
148	Ramon Martinez	318.98
149	Doug Drabek	318.16
150	Jose Jimenez	317.8
151	Scott Sanders	316.29
152	Butch Henry	315.51
153	Frank Castillo	315.45
154	Jeff Suppan	315.24
155	Rafael Roque	314.89
156	Dennis Springer	314.12
157	Roy Halladay	313.03
158	Chris Holt	312.53
159	Joe Nathan	312.24
160	Odalis Perez	311.56
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
161	Kris Benson	311.42
162	Alex Fernandez	310.55
163	Matt Clement	310.23
164	Jose Silva	310.16
165	Stan Spencer	309.89
166	Todd Ritchie	309.31
167	Mike Lincoln	309.16
168	Mike Thurman	308.84
169	Doug Linton	307.84
170	Bill Pulsipher	306.39
171	Bryce Florie	306.22
172	Jim Pittsley	306.12
173	Brian Barber	304.36
174	Allen Watson	304.05
175	Brett Hinchliffe	302.35
176	Jim Abbott	302.33
177	Cal Eldred	302.08
178	Benj Sampson	301.37

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database

None