Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Bill James Starting Pitcher Historical Rankings
Enter morning of date, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
1
Camilo Pascual
507.17
2
Jim Bunning
506.47
3
Sandy Koufax
503.32
4
Whitey Ford
501.85
5
Frank Lary
488.6
6
Warren Spahn
487.83
7
Don Drysdale
474.11
8
Jim O'Toole
471.29
9
Larry Jackson
469.78
10
Don Mossi
465.37
11
Mike McCormick
463.66
12
Chuck Estrada
461.9
13
Steve Barber
458.07
14
Ralph Terry
455.09
15
Milt Pappas
452.97
16
Bill Monbouquette
450.9
17
Bob Friend
447.71
18
Bob Purkey
445.39
19
Johnny Podres
441.17
20
Pedro Ramos
437.09
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
21
Don Cardwell
434.56
22
Juan Pizarro
433.41
23
Billy Pierce
432.31
24
Stan Williams
430.57
25
Ken McBride
423.13
26
Dick Donovan
418.67
27
Curt Simmons
418.16
28
Jack Kralick
417.77
29
Joey Jay
417.5
30
Lew Burdette
415.41
31
Jack Sanford
413.49
32
Bob Shaw
413.38
33
Gary Bell
411.65
34
Art Mahaffey
410.66
35
Ray Herbert
405.33
36
Bennie Daniels
405.24
37
Bill Stafford
405.0
38
Mudcat Grant
404.49
39
Dick Ellsworth
402.71
40
Hal Brown
395.46
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
41
Bob Gibson
395.05
42
Ray Sadecki
394.63
43
Jim Kaat
393.62
44
Joe Gibbon
393.55
45
Ernie Broglio
391.2
46
Bob Buhl
390.19
47
Juan Marichal
388.12
48
John Buzhardt
388.09
49
Gene Conley
388.06
50
Glen Hobbie
387.88
51
Don Schwall
384.9
52
Bud Daley
382.83
53
Early Wynn
382.35
54
Sam Jones
377.48
55
Harvey Haddix
376.31
56
Jim Perry
372.96
57
Jim Archer
371.89
58
Jack Fisher
369.99
59
Billy O'Dell
366.8
60
Eli Grba
365.77
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
61
Carl Willey
364.91
62
Cal McLish
363.84
63
Jerry Walker
355.11
64
Tom Sturdivant
355.04
65
Paul Foytack
354.71
66
Vinegar Bend Mizell
351.87
67
Joe McClain
349.84
68
Norm Bass
345.31
69
Robin Roberts
345.17
70
Ted Bowsfield
339.16
71
Bob Anderson
334.93
72
Ken Johnson
334.31
73
Barry Latman
334.01
74
Ike Delock
332.87
75
Billy Hoeft
332.63
76
Dean Stone
331.98
77
Jack Curtis
328.39
78
Hal Woodeshick
328.35
79
Joe Horlen
326.58
80
Bob Hendley
325.83
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
81
Ed Rakow
325.72
82
Jim Owens
324.37
83
Dick Hall
323.87
84
Jay Hook
323.45
85
Pete Burnside
323.12
86
Bobby Shantz
322.0
87
Ron Kline
321.68
88
Tom Brewer
319.26
89
Rollie Sheldon
318.45
90
Frank Baumann
317.03
91
Ron Taylor
316.48
92
Al McBean
315.85
93
Dean Chance
315.7
94
Galen Cisco
314.58
95
Art Ditmar
314.29
96
John Wyatt
313.81
97
Tracy Stallard
312.58
98
Jack Hamilton
312.43
99
Dan Pfister
311.94
100
Bob Veale
311.68
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
101
Ray Washburn
311.19
102
Cal Koonce
311.05
103
Vern Law
310.03
104
Joe Moeller
309.15
105
Turk Farrell
308.57
106
Art Quirk
307.78
107
Bo Belinsky
307.54
108
Don Lee
306.94
109
Claude Osteen
306.88
110
Frank Sullivan
306.67
111
Sammy Ellis
305.32
112
Dave Giusti
304.71
113
George Witt
304.68
114
Ken Hunt
304.45
115
Jim Coates
304.25
116
Sherman Jones
303.96
117
Roger Craig
303.86
118
Sam McDowell
302.75
119
Phil Regan
302.27
120
Bob Miller
301.42
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
121
Craig Anderson
300.52
122
Moe Drabowsky
300.39
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.