Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Bill James Starting Pitcher Historical Rankings
Enter morning of date, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
1
Curt Schilling
626.26
2
Randy Johnson
620.62
3
Pedro Martinez
612.18
4
Bartolo Colon
545.16
5
Jamie Moyer
541.41
6
Mike Mussina
540.55
7
Roger Clemens
537.62
8
Barry Zito
536.79
9
Greg Maddux
526.74
10
Javier Vazquez
518.89
11
Tim Hudson
517.54
12
Freddy Garcia
515.02
13
Matt Morris
510.08
14
Tom Glavine
509.47
15
Woody Williams
506.7
16
Al Leiter
504.77
17
Jon Lieber
497.85
18
Hideo Nomo
496.57
19
Darryl Kile
494.87
20
Mark Mulder
494.64
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
21
Kevin Millwood
492.88
22
Kerry Wood
492.81
23
Jeff Weaver
491.39
24
Kevin Brown
490.59
25
Russ Ortiz
489.81
26
Randy Wolf
485.96
27
Mark Buehrle
485.85
28
Eric Milton
485.56
29
Roy Halladay
483.69
30
Pedro Astacio
483.44
31
Ramon Ortiz
480.65
32
Chan Ho Park
479.88
33
Roy Oswalt
478.39
34
Jarrod Washburn
477.74
35
Matt Clement
474.46
36
Wade Miller
473.72
37
A.J. Burnett
472.53
38
Kevin Appier
471.87
39
Rick Reed
468.69
40
Elmer Dessens
468.21
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
41
John Burkett
467.69
42
Orlando Hernandez
466.4
43
Chuck Finley
462.68
44
Rick Helling
462.34
45
Tony Armas Jr.
460.33
46
Brad Radke
458.59
47
Jeff Suppan
458.36
48
Aaron Sele
458.04
49
Steve Trachsel
456.93
50
Andy Pettitte
455.31
51
CC Sabathia
453.85
52
Robert Person
452.25
53
Kirk Rueter
449.78
54
Derek Lowe
449.61
55
Jason Schmidt
449.15
56
James Baldwin
447.71
57
Denny Neagle
445.7
58
Livan Hernandez
443.1
59
Jimmy Haynes
442.39
60
Dave Burba
440.07
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
61
Frank Castillo
438.12
62
Brian Lawrence
436.94
63
Sidney Ponson
434.78
64
Kenny Rogers
434.73
65
David Wells
433.84
66
Jason Bere
433.83
67
Ryan Dempster
433.35
68
Shawn Estes
429.58
69
Shawn Chacon
429.42
70
Glendon Rusch
429.41
71
Cory Lidle
429.25
72
Joe Mays
428.96
73
Mark Redman
423.68
74
Odalis Perez
421.34
75
John Thomson
420.68
76
Shane Reynolds
420.35
77
Paul Wilson
420.33
78
Tomo Ohka
419.99
79
Paul Byrd
419.66
80
Kip Wells
419.22
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
81
Tanyon Sturtze
418.35
82
Joe Kennedy
417.68
83
Ben Sheets
416.35
84
Steve Sparks
414.55
85
Chris Carpenter
413.59
86
Mike Hampton
413.05
87
Brian Anderson
412.4
88
Todd Ritchie
412.02
89
Miguel Batista
411.65
90
Omar Daal
411.62
91
Vicente Padilla
411.48
92
Brad Penny
410.75
93
Danys Baez
408.47
94
Ismael Valdez
408.29
95
Jimmy Anderson
407.81
96
Brett Tomko
406.35
97
Jason Johnson
406.34
98
Chris Reitsma
402.77
99
Brandon Duckworth
401.21
100
Terry Adams
401.06
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
101
Rodrigo Lopez
399.65
102
Kazuhisa Ishii
398.78
103
Joel Pineiro
398.34
104
Scott Schoeneweis
397.9
105
Ted Lilly
396.15
106
Jeff D'Amico
395.64
107
Jason Marquis
395.04
108
Kevin Jarvis
394.91
109
Ryan Rupe
394.48
110
Dave Mlicki
394.32
111
Esteban Loaiza
393.89
112
Jason Jennings
390.76
113
Jamey Wright
389.8
114
Doug Davis
389.71
115
Josh Fogg
389.53
116
Andy Ashby
389.47
117
Scott Erickson
388.91
118
Damian Moss
387.47
119
Kyle Lohse
386.76
120
Bobby Jones
386.7
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
121
Jon Garland
385.7
122
Paul Abbott
383.55
123
Dan Wright
382.76
124
Mark Prior
382.25
125
Ruben Quevedo
380.62
126
Albie Lopez
378.14
127
Julian Tavarez
376.4
128
Ryan Jensen
375.39
129
Jason Simontacchi
373.52
130
Rob Bell
371.66
131
Jose Lima
368.45
132
Darren Oliver
367.54
133
Dave Williams
366.98
134
Carlos Hernandez
364.85
135
Josh Beckett
364.17
136
Masato Yoshii
363.81
137
Ryan Drese
362.77
138
Joey Hamilton
362.08
139
Luke Prokopec
360.42
140
Darrell May
358.56
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
141
Tim Redding
356.83
142
Oliver Perez
356.25
143
Michael Tejera
355.81
144
Bruce Chen
355.39
145
Brian Tollberg
349.48
146
Aaron Harang
348.99
147
Johan Santana
348.88
148
Denny Stark
348.8
149
Matt Kinney
347.67
150
Miguel Asencio
345.41
151
Shawn Sedlacek
344.67
152
Kris Benson
344.47
153
Gary Glover
343.6
154
Steve Parris
341.64
155
Chad Durbin
339.04
156
Travis Driskill
337.87
157
Carl Pavano
334.86
158
Rolando Arrojo
334.02
159
Calvin Maduro
333.78
160
Mike Maroth
333.49
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
161
Bud Smith
333.22
162
Adam Bernero
333.12
163
Joe Beimel
332.94
164
Pete Walker
331.2
165
Rafael Soriano
330.79
166
Justin Miller
330.59
167
Carlos Zambrano
330.27
168
Dustin Hermanson
330.16
169
Juan Cruz
329.98
170
Jake Peavy
329.71
171
Nelson Cruz
329.22
172
Brandon Lyon
327.96
173
Peter Munro
327.83
174
Wilson Alvarez
326.83
175
Brian Moehler
326.37
176
John Lackey
326.33
177
Jorge Sosa
325.33
178
Erik Hiljus
324.93
179
Dave Coggin
324.72
180
Jose Cabrera
324.26
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
181
Bryan Rekar
323.92
182
Jason Phillips
320.93
183
Jeremy Affeldt
319.94
184
Kevin Olsen
319.61
185
Jose Acevedo
319.24
186
Blake Stein
318.98
187
Jared Fernandez
318.87
188
Seth Greisinger
318.33
189
Nick Neugebauer
317.31
190
Chris George
317.0
191
Jose Rijo
316.84
192
John Halama
316.19
193
Andy Benes
316.17
194
Runelvys Hernandez
315.81
195
Tim Wakefield
315.33
196
Nelson Figueroa
315.28
197
Josh Towers
314.57
198
Travis Smith
312.34
199
Mike Bacsik
312.04
200
Ron Villone
310.91
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
201
John Patterson
309.71
202
Kirk Saarloos
309.65
203
Charles Nagy
308.93
204
Garrett Stephenson
308.71
205
Juan Rincon
308.49
206
Dennis Tankersley
308.47
207
Mike Thurman
307.35
208
Nate Cornejo
307.08
209
Joaquin Benoit
306.71
210
Ryan Franklin
305.83
211
Travis Harper
305.06
212
Rocky Biddle
304.9
213
Sun-Woo Kim
303.6
214
Kevin Tapani
303.28
215
Delvin James
303.25
216
David Cone
302.89
217
Kevin Pickford
302.87
218
Luis Pineda
302.28
219
Aaron Myette
302.25
220
Zach Day
301.28
Rank
Pitcher
Rating
221
Jaret Wright
300.49
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.