Please help support the Day by Day Database with a donation during the Baseball Musings Pledge Drive.

Baseball Musings Day By Day Database, Bill James Starting Pitcher Historical Rankings

Enter morning of date, then click Submit to see pitchers ranked.

Rank	Pitcher	Rating
1	Roger Clemens	608.43
2	Greg Maddux	592.36
3	Pedro Martinez	587.14
4	John Smoltz	567.61
5	Randy Johnson	559.37
6	David Cone	557.06
7	Mike Mussina	548.86
8	Kevin Appier	546.72
9	Kevin Brown	546.27
10	Pat Hentgen	533.61
11	Alex Fernandez	533.15
12	Curt Schilling	532.96
13	Chuck Finley	526.73
14	Brad Radke	526.66
15	Tom Glavine	526.51
16	Darryl Kile	523.48
17	Denny Neagle	518.81
18	Andy Benes	518.06
19	Andy Pettitte	516.67
20	Wilson Alvarez	508.73
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
21	Jeff Fassero	503.89
22	Hideo Nomo	503.03
23	Todd Stottlemyre	503.0
24	Ben McDonald	502.94
25	Jimmy Key	500.95
26	Charles Nagy	500.01
27	David Wells	497.98
28	Tom Gordon	494.17
29	Ismael Valdes	492.22
30	Al Leiter	488.77
31	Alan Benes	485.88
32	Shane Reynolds	480.18
33	Scott Erickson	477.34
34	John Smiley	470.83
35	Orel Hershiser	470.4
36	Tim Wakefield	469.95
37	Joey Hamilton	467.06
38	John Burkett	465.88
39	Steve Trachsel	464.15
40	Bobby Jones	462.1
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
41	Bobby Witt	461.48
42	Ramon Martinez	461.11
43	Ken Hill	460.91
44	Mike Hampton	460.23
45	Tim Belcher	458.34
46	Pedro Astacio	454.26
47	Scott Karl	452.94
48	Justin Thompson	452.55
49	Juan Guzman	452.31
50	Darren Oliver	451.82
51	Allen Watson	451.04
52	Andy Ashby	450.87
53	Mark Gardner	448.41
54	Terry Mulholland	444.25
55	James Baldwin	441.79
56	Doug Drabek	440.24
57	Jose Rosado	440.04
58	Dave Burba	439.72
59	Matt Morris	435.57
60	Jaime Navarro	435.44
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
61	Shawn Estes	432.78
62	Mark Clark	432.36
63	Bob Tewksbury	432.34
64	Francisco Cordova	430.18
65	Frank Castillo	429.99
66	Jamie Moyer	427.81
67	Cal Eldred	427.68
68	Kevin Foster	427.48
69	Chan Ho Park	423.35
70	Danny Darwin	422.62
71	Kirk Rueter	422.27
72	Omar Olivares	421.52
73	Felipe Lira	421.17
74	Aaron Sele	420.99
75	Rick Reed	420.35
76	Sterling Hitchcock	420.2
77	Kevin Ritz	417.89
78	Jason Schmidt	417.77
79	Jon Lieber	414.71
80	Carlos Perez	414.16
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
81	Kenny Rogers	413.52
82	Jason Dickson	412.83
83	Mark Leiter	412.28
84	Jack McDowell	411.87
85	Roger Bailey	410.92
86	Jeff Juden	408.08
87	Jeff D'Amico	407.07
88	Steve Avery	406.73
89	Rich Robertson	406.12
90	Armando Reynoso	406.02
91	Pat Rapp	405.89
92	Woody Williams	405.59
93	Steve Cooke	404.35
94	Chad Ogea	402.36
95	Roger Pavlik	400.96
96	Dave Mlicki	400.05
97	William Van Landingham	399.7
98	Erik Hanson	397.38
99	Donovan Osborne	396.06
100	Mike Morgan	395.96
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
101	Scott Kamieniecki	395.8
102	Brian Moehler	394.48
103	Chris Holt	393.57
104	Ariel Prieto	392.8
105	Mark Portugal	392.68
106	Fernando Valenzuela	392.64
107	Dustin Hermanson	389.53
108	Willie Blair	389.08
109	John Thomson	387.79
110	Robert Person	387.33
111	Bob Wolcott	386.4
112	Kent Mercker	385.32
113	Esteban Loaiza	385.03
114	Dennis Springer	384.32
115	Dwight Gooden	384.26
116	Steve Karsay	381.73
117	Mark Langston	374.6
118	Dennis Martinez	374.34
119	Jose Mercedes	374.31
120	Jeremi Gonzalez	372.74
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
121	Jeff Suppan	369.56
122	Jim Bullinger	368.97
123	Pete Schourek	368.03
124	Osvaldo Fernandez	367.96
125	Tony Saunders	367.41
126	Jamey Wright	367.15
127	Frank Rodriguez	366.97
128	Garrett Stephenson	364.77
129	Pete Harnisch	362.85
130	Brett Tomko	361.89
131	Scott Sanders	361.5
132	Tom Candiotti	359.73
133	Ramon Garcia	357.0
134	Livan Hernandez	355.55
135	Shawn Boskie	352.98
136	Chris Haney	352.56
137	Glendon Rusch	350.65
138	Matt Beech	348.49
139	Dave Telgheder	347.79
140	Mark Thompson	347.69
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
141	Mike Oquist	346.95
142	Brad Rigby	346.19
143	Scott Aldred	345.65
144	Jim Pittsley	345.5
145	Rocky Coppinger	342.07
146	Ramiro Mendoza	340.22
147	Jaret Wright	340.21
148	John Wasdin	338.53
149	Bartolo Colon	337.95
150	Ricky Bones	337.78
151	Donne Wall	335.82
152	Bill Swift	332.16
153	LaTroy Hawkins	330.02
154	Derek Lowe	328.69
155	Kevin Tapani	328.19
156	Brian Anderson	325.22
157	Willie Adams	325.0
158	Don Wengert	324.86
159	John Burke	324.7
160	Julio Santana	324.64
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
161	Pete Smith	324.31
162	Bryce Florie	323.97
163	Brian Bohanon	323.45
164	Tim Worrell	321.79
165	Tyler Green	319.91
166	Carlos Reyes	318.2
167	Matt Perisho	317.87
168	Vaughn Eshelman	317.09
169	Rick Helling	316.71
170	Sean Bergman	316.58
171	Darren Holmes	316.42
172	Terrell Wade	316.21
173	Chris Hammond	316.16
174	Steve Woodard	315.68
175	Calvin Maduro	315.6
176	Jimmy Haynes	315.26
177	Keith Foulke	314.53
178	Dave Stevens	314.0
179	Terry Clark	314.0
180	Shane Bowers	312.98
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
181	Jason Jacome	312.91
182	Kevin Millwood	312.91
183	Mike Mohler	312.26
184	Danny Jackson	311.79
185	Dennys Reyes	311.46
186	Chris Brock	310.93
187	Hideki Irabu	309.9
188	Mike Remlinger	309.02
189	Paul Byrd	308.81
190	Rick Krivda	308.73
191	Doug Creek	308.48
192	Luis Andujar	308.45
193	Amaury Telemaco	308.15
194	Glenn Dishman	307.99
195	Joel Adamson	306.24
196	Travis Miller	306.08
197	Scott Ruffcorn	305.67
198	Rheal Cormier	305.21
199	Albie Lopez	304.14
200	Chris Carpenter	303.77
Rank	Pitcher	Rating
201	Will Cunnane	303.76
202	Mike Johnson	303.42
203	Tanyon Sturtze	303.08
204	Manny Aybar	302.8
205	Giovanni Carrara	302.38
206	Steve Wojciechowski	302.27
207	Brian Rose	301.14
208	Bryan Rekar	300.81
209	Kevin Gross	300.79
210	Chris Clemons	300.76
211	Tommy Greene	300.74
212	Jose Alberro	300.2

The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711. Newer data was purchased from Baseball Info Solutions.

Baseball Musings home
Day by Day Database

None