Category Archives: History

June 23, 2024

Wertz, Mays, and Buffalo

Sean Kirst spoke with the family of Vic Wertz, the Cleveland player who hit the ball on which Willie Mays made his famous World Series catch. (May require a subscription.)

For Mays to make such a celestial catch, you needed someone who could hit this Valhalla of a ball.

To Terry Wertz and his daughter Rachel, who both had such a keen sense of loss this week, that is what binds Willie Mays and Vic Wertz.

BuffaloNews.com

Wertz played minor league baseball in Buffalo, where he was ready to quit after struggling:

Upon returning in 1946, Wertz batted .301, with 19 home runs and 91 runs batted in. Brian Frank – a baseball historian and founder of the Herd Chronicles – found some newspaper clippings that underline how crucial that season was for Wertz.

According to an early season account by Cy Kritzer of The Buffalo Evening News, Wertz changed his batting stance and prospered as a hitter after a “former major leaguer … passed on the tip” about Wertz’s form to Bisons manager Gabby Hartnett, now in baseball’s Hall of Fame.

It was career-saving advice. Wertz later told Kritzer he had been so frustrated he was ready to give up the game.

The other side of the out is interesting, too.

June 20, 2024

Reggie Wins the Pregame

If you missed it, Fox had Reggie Jackson on during the pre-game show to the Rickwood Field game. Reggie played minor league ball in Birmingham for the Athletics, the first integrated team to play in the city. That A’s team which employed a number of the future World Champions, was considered one of the best minor league teams of all time. They asked Reggie if coming back made him emotional about the team.

The short version of his answer was that he would not wish his experience on anyone.

I hope Fox posts the whole, raw, response.

Update: Here it is.

April 14, 2024

You Don’t Tug on Superman’s Cape

Triston Casas throws shade on Ted Williams home run seat.

The Red Sox first baseman expressed doubts over Ted Williams’s famous home run after hitting a 429-foot homer in Saturday’s 7-2 win over the Angels.

“That’s my best ball, for sure,” Casas told reporters of his homer, which had 111.9 mph exit velocity. “I had one hit harder, exit velo-wise, last year. But that Ted Williams seat is starting to feel more and more like a myth.”

Boston.com

David Ortiz expressed similar thoughts.

I was at a game in the early 1980s when Reggie Jackson hit a home run half-way up the rightfield seats, which I thought was a monster shot. (Very likely this game.) Since then, Fenway underwent numerous remodels, the most impactful might be the addition of a new press box behind home plate. The taller structure changed the wind currents of the part, and ball appear not to be blown as much when they are hit with a high arch. so it could both be true that Williams hit the seat, and that it may not be possible to reach the seat today.

February 11, 2024 February 9, 2024

Power and Speed at Second

The Jose Altuve contract inspires Cybermetrics to look at the history of second basemen hitting home runs and stealing bases. Joe Morgan unsurprisingly served as the trailblazer.

The Day by Day Database holds 50 years of situational hitting data, including by defensive position. You can see how the home run profile of second baseman changed over that period:

DecadeSecond Basemen HR Percentage (per PA)
1974-19831.00%
1984-19931.25%
1994-20031.72%
2004-20132.03%
2014-20232.47%
Powe increase by second basemen

While part of that is just that batters hit more home runs overall, the other three positions don’t show the steady rise. First base, third base, and shortstop all saw the percentage drop in the 2004-2013 stretch as PED testing came into existence. (Note, however, that in the last decade, shortstops now exceed second baseman in HR percentage at 2.52%.)

February 7, 2024

DiMaggio’s Payday

On this day in 1949, Joe DiMaggio became the first MLB player to receive a $100,000 contract (video at the link). Note that at the time, there was no free agency, and the only way to try to negotiate a better deal was to “hold out,” basically refusing to play. DiMaggio’s $100,000 would be worth about $1.28 million today. Note that as a five WAR player, DiMaggio might be worth $40 to $50 million a year today.

That demonstrates both the value of free agency and the growth of the game. The two go hand in had.

February 4, 2024 January 25, 2024

Royals Helping History

The Royals will once again provide the price of admission to the Negro League Baseball Museum in February:

“We are excited to help Kansas Citians learn about the incredible story of the Negro Leagues,” Luis Maes, Royals Vice President of Community Impact, said in a news release. “It’s a story about baseball as well as American history and our struggles and progress in civil rights. The NLBM is the only museum in the world dedicated to bringing this incredible story to life and we are fortunate to have it in our backyard.” The Kansas City Royals Foundation (formerly Royals Charities) paid $120,000 last year after more than 14,000 people visited the NLBM, the team said.

Read more at: https://www.kansascity.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/for-petes-sake/article284661760.html#storylink=cpy

KansasCity.com

If you’re in Kansas City next month, I hope you take advantage of the offer.

January 7, 2024

McCutchen Talks Pirates

Andrew McCutchen proves to be an astute observer of Pittsburgh sports history a the Pirates Fan Fest.

“There have been a lot of fans who have been part of it, fans who are older who have seen the ’79 and ’71 World Series teams. They know what that’s like. I truly believe this was a baseball city before it was a hockey or football city. Nothing against the Pens or the Steelers. Great teams. Great franchises. But history has it. I believe that everyone looked at the Pirates at one point. It would be nice for us to be able to build that back up again.”

“I’ve said it before: There are bad teams, and then sometimes there are good teams that put themselves in bad situations,” McCutchen said. “I felt like that’s what happened here. This is a good team. It’s just finding yourself, knowing who you are as a team, going out there and putting it on the field.”

Post-Gazette.com

The Pirates are a young team. With another year of maturity, they’re more likely to find themselves. McCutchen can help them conserve outs, expanding the offensive context for everyone else.

December 15, 2023

Rookie Burned

Cy Morong looks at pitchers who led the league in WAR at age 21 or younger. There are famous names there for various reasons, but the not famous name belongs to Britt Burns of the White Sox, who posted a seven rWAR in 1980:

Burns is probably, by far, the least known. Mathewson, Feller and Drysdale are Hall of Famers. Gooden and Saberhagen won Cy Young awards. 

Fydrich was famous in his rookie year for his mound antics like talking to the baseball. When he started, Tiger Stadium was usually packed. He started the All-Star game for the AL in 1976. He was also rookie of the year

Burns made the AL All-Star team in 1981 but did not pitch. He was 5th in pitching WAR that year.

Cybermetric.Blogspot.com

A degenerative hip condition ended his career early.

Burns pitched a lot in 1980, logging 238 innings and completing eleven games. Amazingly, he finished fifth in the Rookie of the Year voting! I suspect his 15-13 record, rather than the 2.84 ERA, was weighted more heavily by the voters back then. In that regard, times have changed for the better.

November 29, 2023

Dominant Pitchers

The Bill James Pitcher Ranking provides a way to look at how much a particular pitcher dominated during his tenure in the majors. The following table show most days in first place during a career since 1940* during the competitive part of the year, April through October:

PitcherDays in First
Roger Clemens1288
Sandy Koufax943
Clayton Kershaw858
Robin Roberts808
Tom Seaver795
Pedro Martinez775
Hal Newhouser771
Greg Maddux760
Randy Johnson746
Johan Santana677
Steve Carlton672
Gerrit Cole670
Max Scherzer583
Bob Gibson533
Bob Feller524
Justin Verlander482
Warren Spahn471
Mort Cooper451
Days in First Place, 1940-2023

If Cole produces another dominant season in 2024, with 180 days in first place, he moves up to fourth on the list.

Note that many of the pitchers on the list are rather modern. Two reasons come to mind on this front:

  1. Baseball became better over time at preventing injuries, especially serious shoulder injuries. Even with all the elbow blow outs, many good pitcher returns from TJ and pitch well.
  2. It may be easier to be dominant during a high offensive era, as most pitchers get knocked around. See the long term domination of Clemens, Maddux, Martinez, and Johnson during and just after the PED era.

That makes Koufax’s domination even more impressive. A major injury shortened his career, and he pitched in a relatively low offensive era.

Keep your eye on Cole. He may wind up very close to the top of this list.

August 23, 2023

Fats Johnson

Harry Lewis, one of the best reasons to go to Harvard, and Kasey Uhlenhuth discuss the life of Arthur Augustus Johnson in Harvard Magazine. “Fats” Johnson, as he was known, developed one of the best Negro League teams in the Boston area, the Tigers:

As early as 1912, Johnson—an athletic 5’11”, 180 pounds before he earned his nickname—was playing baseball while off duty in Boston. The “Great Migration” of Southern blacks was bringing more African Americans to Roxbury, where several ball fields were available to all-black teams.

A decade later, Johnson was managing and promoting Boston’s most successful black baseball team, the Boston Tigers. He lined up opponents across New England and even in Canada. The “money man” for the team, he handled the business side of the games. The team was never fully professional, but as an allegedly amateur team, it could play games and collect receipts on Sundays, when professional games were banned. “Oh for the good ole Boston Tigers days when ole Carter Field was the haven of many a baseball classic,” “Sheep” Jackson told the Boston Chronicle in 1942, referring to what is now a Northeastern University athletic facility on Columbus Avenue.

Johnson made the transition from Pullman porter to baseball impresario with the help of connections he made at Harvard, where he became a celebrated figure for reasons unrelated to baseball.

HarvardMagzine.com

He also did a great business supplying Harvard undergraduates with liquor during prohibition. It’s a great story of a man who saw opportunities for business and seized them.

I also noticed in the latest issue of the magazine that a classmate of mine, Bruce Schoenfeld published a book on the rise of analytics in sports. Game of Edges is available at Amazon.

August 18, 2023 July 24, 2023

The Pine Tar Game

Today is the 40th anniversary of the Pine Tar Game, in which George Brett temporarily lost a home run because the pine tar on his bat was too high toward the barrel. The announcers discussed this during the Sunday Night Baseball broadcast, but they left out a reason the Yankees thought they could get Brett. Years before, Lou Piniella lost a hit (I believe it was in Minnesota) because the Twins complained he had too much pine tar on the bat. So there was precedent for taking away a hit, and the Yankees had suffered it. (I watched both games, so when they took away Brett’s homer, I was not surprised.)

The announcers did make a point that I hadn’t heard before. Eduardo Perez noted that pine tar was used to hide alterations to the bat that would help with putting spin the batter ball. Not:

The rulebook provision was meant to avoid dirtying too many baseballs, not to affect the outcome of a play or game.

ESPN.com

I suspect MLB did not want to promote the idea that batters were cheating, just like they underplayed steroid use for years. Dirty baseball strike me as a convenient cover story.

June 22, 2023

A Zero Disappears

Joe Ryan of the Twins pitches an efficient high-strikeout game to defeat the Red Sox 6-0. He earns both his first career shutout and his first career complete game. Most pitchers today have zeros for their careers in both column. This table shows how both type of results disappeared over the decades:

Decade years run from 1 to 10 (1961 to 1970)
Decade Starts CG ShO CGPct ShOPct
1920 24663 11925 1235 48.35 10.36
1930 24631 10979 1348 44.57 12.28
1940 24758 10458 1719 42.24 16.44
1950 24743 7956 1521 32.15 19.12
1960 33290 8233 2094 24.73 25.43
1970 39924 10041 2285 25.15 22.76
1980 40674 5922 1541 14.56 26.02
1990 43836 3015 919 6.88 30.48
2000 48584 1670 647 3.44 38.74
2010 45530 904 437 1.99 48.34
2020 11950 101 54 0.85 53.47

The big fall off started in the 1950s. There was a brief pause the 1970s as teams started going to five man rotations. The 1980s then accelerated the trend until now less than one percent of starts end in a complete game.

The last column shows shutouts as a percentage of complete games. As complete games disappeared, only the best pitched games led to CGs, and shutouts are about the best one can do.

That’s what Ryan did on Thursday. He threw 112 pitches to 30 batters, 3.7 per batter. He walked none, and struck out nine. With 29 pitches called balls, he didn’t go very deep in counts often.

Ryan’s ERA falls to 2.98.

April 18, 2023

Yankee Stadium Centenial

Today marks 100 years since the opening of “The House that Ruth Built”, the original Yankee Stadium. Joe Guzzardi sends along this guest post:

Opening Day, 1923, the ‘House that Ruth Built’ Begins the Golden Age Baseball Era

Opening Day, 1923, a century ago, dawned cloudy and cold. Babe Ruth woke up in his plush Upper West Side Ansonia Hotel apartment and prepared to play the first-ever game in the brand-new edifice that would become known as the “House that Ruth Built.” Always a snappy dresser, Ruth donned his perfectly tailored suit, then around noon, hopped into his Pierce-Arrow automobile to drive to the Bronx. Had the weather been warmer, Ruth would have selected his sporty Stutz Bearcat.

A notoriously reckless motorist, Ruth had been involved in numerous minor collisions and rarely held a valid driver’s license. To avoid incidents, the Yankees’ owner, Col. Jacob Ruppert, sent police to escort the “Big Bam” safely to the stadium. Along the way, Ruth stopped to sign a few autographs and invited some kids to join him as he roared along.

The largest baseball crowd ever – 74,000, with 25,000 turned away – witnessed a pre-game ceremony befitting the stadium’s grandeur. While New York Gov. Al Smith looked on, John Phillip Sousa led the Seventh Regiment Army Band in full military dress onto the field.

In 1923, Ruth was on a redemption mission, and the new Yankee Stadium, the biggest and most lavish ever built, was the perfect place to carry out his undertaking. Ruth considered his 1922 season a failure. His performance at the plate, for him a paltry .315 batting average with 35 home runs and 99 RBIs, a sharp drop off from 1921, embarrassed Ruth. Moreover, during the season, Ruth was suspended five times. Worst of all, Ruth’s final 1922 baseball appearance was against the New York Giants in the World Series in which Ruth hit a pathetic .188. Giants’ manager John McGraw called every pitch from the bench. Some were slow curves that Ruth swung on, twisting himself into a corkscrew while missing by a mile. During the off-season, McGraw, a scientific baseball genius, chided Ruth whose style of play – the long ball – he disdained. McGraw called Ruth “the Big Baboon” and incorrectly predicted that the home run fad would soon die out. The media and fans got on Ruth too. The New York Sun labeled Ruth “an exploded phenomenon,” and for the first time, Ruth heard boos.

A humbled Ruth vowed to make amends, on and off the field. Over the winter months, Ruth said that liquor never touched his lips. And now the day had come, April 18, against the last place Boston Red Sox, for Ruth to regain respect and admiration from teammates and his millions of fans. Before the game, Ruth said in the locker room that he would “give a year off his life” to hit a homer in the season opener.

Red Sox starter Howard Ehmke, taking a page out of McGraw’s book, tossed junk balls to Ruth, and in the first inning the Bambino flied out. The third inning, however, was a different story. With two Yankees on base, Ruth deposited a titanic homer ten rows back in the right-field bleachers. Rush’s blast made the score 4-0, a lead the Yankees never relinquished.

As the season unfolded, Ruth and the Yankees dominated. The Yankees won the American League pennant by 16 games over the Cleveland Indians. Ruth hit .393, 41 homers, and unanimously won the Most Valuable Player award. Rules at the time prevented any player from winning the MVP more than once.

More, greater redemption awaited Ruth. For the third straight year, the Yankees would meet the Giants in the World Series. In 1921 and 1922, McGraw’s pitch calling and inside baseball strategy outsmarted the Yankees. But, in 1923, the tables turned on McGraw. The Yankees won the series 4-2, Ruth hit .368, three homers, had a .556 on base percentage, and slugged 1.000. A reporter wrote that when one of Ruth’s shots, a 450-foot job, returned to earth, “the ball was covered in ice.”

In defeat, McGraw was uncharacteristically gracious. He strode over to the winners’ locker room to shake hands with everyone – except the Babe. McGraw preferred to talk about the Giants’ hitting star who almost outshone Ruth. Casey Stengel hit .417 with two homers.

Yankee Stadium became a cash cow for Ruppert who reinvested his money in the team’s future, a decision that kept the Yankees atop the American League for years to come. The original Yankee Stadium no longer stands. In 2009, the first game at the new venue took place, and today’s Yankee Stadium is rarely referred to as the “House that Ruth Built.” But Ruth, McGraw and Stengel, despite having passed years ago, are still alive in baseball fans’ hearts.

Joe Guzzardi is a Society for American Baseball Research and Internet Baseball Writers Association member.

November 1, 2022

Bohm Bomb

Alec Bohm leads off the bottom of the second inning by hitting the 1000th home run in World Series history! His shot into the leftfield stands give the Phillies a 3-0 lead over the Astros. It’s Bohm’s first post-season home run.

Update: Brandon Marsh adds a two-out solo homer that just hits the top of the wall in right. That gives the Phillies a 4-0 lead.

October 27, 2022

Win Differential

Big Bad Baseball looks at the World Series in the context of win differential, the Astros and Phillies separated by nineteen wins. That’s not the highest of all time, but it does rank second to the 1906 championship, won by the underdog.

The most fascinating thing to me is that pre-expansion, World Series where the teams were separated by ten wins or more were dominated by the team with the better record, 12-2. Since expansion, that record is 7-7. We worry about tanking and so forth, but in general baseball is much more balanced in the last 60+ years than before that. An 87 win team might intrinsically be 97 win team that had bad luck, or a 77 win team that had good luck. It’s why I tend to keep my probabilities of a favorite winning a series below 60%. Teams are just to close to each other to say for sure which is really better.

October 19, 2022 July 19, 2022

Alternative Captain

Jonathan Papelbon wants ESPN to produce a series about Jason Varitek:

Here is my commentary on the fight.

After watching a few times, I decided Alex Rodriguez said, “F-U, F-U Mother F’r, you want a piece of me.” Obviously, Varitek did.

April 23, 2022

Big Shutouts

The Tigers shutout the Rockies 13-0 in the first game of their doubleheader, then the Cubs shutout the Pirates 21-0 in their game at Wrigley Field. It was nice to see some high scores, but it would have been nice if the losing team had contributed.

This is the first time having two shutouts of 13 runs or more since April 7, 2013. That day, the Red Sox shutout the Blue Jays, and the Indians shut out the Rays, both by a score of 13-0. The only other time it happened since 1920 was on August 8, 2012. That day, the Marlins shutout the Mets 13-0 while the Giants downed the Cardinals 15-0. There are still a few games left, so maybe MLB can set a record with a third blowout shutout on the day!

There have now been 338 of these 13+ run shutouts since 1920.

April 15, 2022 January 9, 2022

Wood Pile

David Laurila talks about the greatness of Wilbur Wood in his Sunday notes column. Laurila does touch upon one of Wood’s worst days, when he started both ends of a doubleheader against the Yankees. He did not record an out in game one, then got hammered in 4+ innings in game two. I have a vague memory of being at the annual festival at the Syrian Orthodox church in Bridgeport that day, and getting snippets of the games from radios. I probably saw the first game at home, then was very surprised to see Wood start game two. All in all he faced 27 batter, walked one, hit a batter, struck out two, and allowed 13 hits.

August 12, 2021 July 16, 2021 April 14, 2021 February 25, 2021

Ranking Negro League Players

538 does a nice job of comparing Negro league players to both current MLB players and MLB Hall of Famers using WAR/162 games. There’s a great graph showing the distribution of this statistic among the three groups. The final result is an interactive set of cards for the best players of the Negro Leagues, showing their strengths and weakness with comparisons to MLB players. This is a great research resource.

February 12, 2021

Good, But Not Good Enough

Bill James looks at the history of teams that could not turn regular season success into post-season success. One of the more interesting bits comes in Section V, where most of the long-term success in both regular and post-season play is concentrated in six teams.

I am printing the chart, really, so that you can see where “your” team ranks on the chart.  The Yankees over a long period of time have enjoyed almost twice as much success per season as any other team, which is not surprising.  But this is surprising, to me.   The average level of success for all teams, per season, is 20.5 LBS points.  But only six teams—three in each league—meet that standard.   The only teams that have an “average” level of success, over time, are the Yankees, Red Sox and A’s in the American League, and the Dodgers, Giants and Cardinals in the National League.  All other teams, over time, have been below average.

BillJamesOnline.com

According to this method, the Diamondbacks and Rays are the most successful expansion franchises, and I have to believe a smaller sample size and an easier path to a division title had something to do with that.

February 10, 2021

Young Joe

A friend sent a link to this heart-warming story about the youngest person to play professional baseball, Joe Louis Reliford.

There it was, it’s almost too unbelievable to be real: A five-foot, 12-year-old child standing in against a six-foot, 24-year-old man named Curtis White. The crowd was on edge, happy they got what they wanted and excited for whatever might happen next.

MLB.com

The whole story is well worth your read.

February 8, 2021