December 17, 2003

Independent Leagues

The Cub Reporter has an interview with Dave Kaval, who is starting up an independent league in California. The model for this league will be a bit different, where the league owns all the teams.

TCR: You mentioned single-entity ownership. Does that mean that, rather than each team having owners, the league will have investors who have a piece of each team?
DK: No, there’ll be owners, it’s just that they’ll own the whole league. Rather than owning the team in, say, Long Beach, they own a piece of all the teams. For them, it’s a little bit of a portfolio strategy — they have multiple franchises, so if they do all right in three places, and not so well in three others, overall they’re still doing pretty decently.
TCR: So it’s minimizing risk, in many ways.
DK: Yes. And, I think the control aspect is very, very important. We can manage the product in all the different locations and make sure the experience for the fan is the best that it can be in all locations. In a franchise-oriented league, the individual owners are going to put the kind of product out there that they want. Hopefully it’s great in all locations, but more often than not — in a lot of these leagues you have up to 25% of the ownership groups that are undercapitalized, aren’t really running it like a business. In those cases, it’s not a good fan experience, and that hurts the whole league. And then those teams start moving around, playing musical chairs, and that hurts the cities. It creates a lot of turbulence and ill will. We feel that starting anew, starting with single-entity ownership, having a little more control — in the early years especially — is going to prevent a lot of that.
TCR: Do you see single-entity ownership as a long-term business model, or is it simply a way to provide stability at the inception of the league, and will you be looking to eventually sell the teams to individual owners?
DK: We see single-entity as a long term business model. We have no plans to sell off individual franchises. However, we would consider selling the league as a whole. We feel that the benefits of single entity — stability, enhanced revenue opportunities, aligned incentives, other entertainment options — make such a framework superior to the traditional franchise set up especially for municipalities and fans.

It’s an interesting idea. It makes one wonder however, if the league will move the better players to the better markets, as happened when multiple major league teams were owned by one person in the 1890’s. I do hope it works out, however. The independent league games I’ve attended have been a lot of fun. It will be a great addition to the California baseball landscape.

4 thoughts on “Independent Leagues

  1. Christian

    David,
    I asked Dave that, not in the interview but in a different conversation, and he assured me that each team would have total control over its players.
    I had the same fear, just like I had it with MLS soccer and the late, lamented ABL (women’s basketball league). As far as I know, it didn’t happen in either of those cases, but I always thought about it.

  2. Bob T

    I wish the guy luck, but the independent league operations out here in California just have always seemed very well… minor league. Even compared to the relatively “slick” California League.
    The Cal League has done a good job of covering most parts of the state with exposure to a team. About the only places that are shut out are the Central Coast and the North Coast.
    Unless they are planning to put a team in Alturas or Redding.

  3. Christian

    I think one severely under-served area is the Bay Area. You’ve got the SJ Giants down the peninsula, and the Ports in Stockton, and that’s it. I think a team in the East Bay and/or on the Peninsula would draw well.
    Same thing in LA, actually — you have teams in Rancho C, Lancaster, San Bernardino, Lake Elsinore, and Adelanto, but all of those are at least 40 miles away. I think a team or two closer-in would draw well.
    I wouldn’t be surprised to see a team in Redding, by the way. I forsee a string of teams inland: Medford-Redding-Chico-Fresno-Bakersfield, maybe Palm Springs or Yuma (though it’s damn hot there in the summer), and then 2 teams in the SF Bay area and 2 in the LA area…

  4. Bob T

    There has been two attempts at a team in Long Beach and neither has been successful.
    Redding is damn hot in the summertime also. Almost as hot as Palm Springs.
    Ventura and Santa Barbara don’t have any teams and the one attempt at a Cal League team in that area a few years back really tanked.

Comments are closed.