Tag Archives: Jim Bagby

October 10, 2020

This Date in 1920

The Indians host the Dodgers for game five of the World Series on October 10, 1920. Hyperbole filled the sports writing of the time, but the opening paragraph of the page one game story gets it just right:

In the most spectacular game ever staged in a world’s series, the Brooklyn Dodgers were overwhelmed by the Cleveland Indians in this city to-day by the score of 8 to 1. Everything that could be crowded into a single game was there. For the first time in the history of the game there was a home run with the bases filled and a triple play unassisted.

New York Tribune

The news story actually misses another record set in the game. Cleveland starting pitcher Jim Bagby homered. In the fourth inning:

Doc Johnston shot a hit off Grimes’s knee into center field. He flitted to second on a passed ball. With Sewell out, Grimes meditated for a few moments and concluded to pass O’Neill for Sergeant Jim Bagby. The multitude protested with raucous voices. Grimes had plenty of time to repent this picking of batters.

Sergeant Jim Bagby lifted the pill right over into the newly constructed bleachers in right center field. It was not much of a blow, but it went for a home run, and a home run is a home run. The blow brought over three more runs for the Cleveland Indians, and Burleigh Grimes, with his tow head bowed on his chest, shuffled to the dugout.

New York Tribune

With that blow, Bagby hit the first World Series home run by a pitcher.

The grand slam in the first inning had a great setup. Charlie Jamieson, leading off, singled off the leg of the first baseman. Bill Wambsganss, “after tapping more fouls than he has consonants in his name,” hit a clean single between third and short. Tris Speaker, the number three hitter and one of the best best batters in the game that year, player-manager of the Indians , decided to sacrifice. Burleigh Grimes slipped trying to field the ball, and the play went for a single to load the bases. Up comes Elmer Smith:

Elmer took two hearty and husky swings on nothing. Then it came — for the first time in a world’s series — a home run with the bases filled. It was a straight ball and just where Elmer wanted it. Bob Shawkey, during the late lamented American League series, gave Elmer that kind of ball here and Elmer mussed up the adjacent scenery with it. To-day he lifted the pill over the right field fence onto a roof crowded with local bugs and the bases were cleared for four runs.

New York Tribune

Smith also tripled and singled in the game, by far the best offensive game of the day.

The triple play was what you might expect. In the top of the fifth inning, the Dodgers used two singles to put runners on first and second:

Mitchell, the left-hander, slashed a hard one at Wambsganss. It sounded like a hit and it looked like a hit; everybody started to travel. Wamby made a desperate stab and held the ball. A cool person is this man of many consonants. He stepped over a pace, doubling Kilduff. In the mean time Miller continued to flounder toward second. Wamby reached out and tagged him.

New York Tribune

Note that even though Jim Bagby allowed just one run for the complete game victory, he didn’t pitch that well. He allowed 13 hits to the Dodgers, while Cleveland collected 12. (The Indians did walk four times, while the Dodgers did not draw a base on balls.) The Dodgers, however, kept losing base runners. In addition to the two on the triple play, Cleveland turned three double plays and threw out a runner at the plate. Brooklyn centerfielder Hi Myers attempted two steals and was caught twice. That’s eight runners taken off base.

The Indians now hold a 3-2 lead in the series, and if they sweep at home, the best of nine match will be over.

October 2, 2020

This Date in 1920

It’s the penultimate day of the regular season as all eleven major league games scheduled for October 2, 1920, play to a decision. That includes doubleheaders in Boston and Philadelphia, and a tripleheader in Pittsburgh. The Cardinals beat the Cubs 4-1 in Chicago for the low scoring game of the day. Two games result in seventeen runs. The Reds beat the Pirates 13-4 in the first game of their tripleheader, as Cincinnati takes two out of three games to finish 82-70 on the year. The Pirates win game three 6-0 in six innings, the contest ended by darkness. The White Sox defeat the Browns 10-7, as the remaining stars hit well on the day.

For the White Sox, it’s not enough as Cleveland pounds Detroit 10-1 to clinch the AL pennant. Jim Bagby collects his 31st win of the season, and Tris Speaker goes three for six to raise his batting average to .387.

Jimmy Dykes of the Athletics takes home the best offensive game of the day. He posts a two for three with two home runs and two walks in the second game of the Senators-Athletics twin bill. That’s not enough to prevent a loss however, as the Senators sweep with a 4-3 victory.

Ferdie Schupp of the Cardinals wins the best pitched game of the day for his victory against the Cubs. Schupp gives up six hits and three walks, leading to one run. He also struck out six. Schupp peaked early in his career. He was a big reason the Giants won the pennant in 1917. His combined rWAR in 1916-1917 stood at 9.6; for his career his total was 5.5. He posted an 0.90 ERA in 1916 in 140 1/3 innings, and followed that up with a 1.95 ERA in 1917 in 272 innings.

Then his arm went:

“But that winter I went to a camp,” Schupp recalled. “There was snow on the ground, I think maybe I caught cold in the arm, though it didn’t bother me then, but the next spring I was up against it. The very first ball I tried to pitch in spring training, a sharp pain struck through my shoulder and my arm went dead. I couldn’t do anything with it.”24 Conversely, there were later rumors that the easy-going left-hander had injured his arm in a fight that offseason.25 Still another report had him hurting his arm while pitching during spring training at the Giants training camp in Marlin, Texas.26

SABR.org

This was all too common in that era.

George Sisler posts a two for five day to keep his average at .406, and there is little doubt he’ll hit .400 for the season. His record hit total now stands at 254.

The New York Tribune devotes page 20 and page 21 to the upcoming World Series, with pictures of the players framing each page. Jim Baby will start game one in Brooklyn against Burleigh Grimes. Grantland Rice gives the edge to the Dodgers based on superior pitching.

September 28, 2020

This Date in 1920

September 28, 1920, proves to be a dark day in the history of baseball. The White Sox scandal gets a four column headline on page one of the New York Tribune, and takes up all of page two as Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson confess their guilt to the grand jury in Chicago.

Indictments were voted against eight baseball stars to-day, confessions were obtained from two of them, and Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the oft-time champion Chicago White Sox, smashed his pennant chasing machine to clean up baseball. The confessions told how the Sox threw last year’s world championship to Cincinnati for money paid by gamblers.

New York Tribune

Comiskey paid off the eight players and suspended them for the rest of the season. This basically killed Chicago’s hope of catching Cleveland for the AL pennant. It the day the Chicago American League Club became the Black Sox.

On the field, five of the six games scheduled in the major leagues play to completion, including two doubleheaders. The Reds beat the Pirates at home 2-0 in game one of their twin bill for the low scoring game of the day. The Indians beat the Browns in St. Louis 9-5 for the high scoring game of the day.

Eddie Foster of the Red Sox takes home the honor of best offensive game of the day. He posts a four for five day in game one, missing the cycle by a homer as he collects two doubles and a triple. The Senators win that game 7-6 in ten innings. Foster collected 23 extra-base hits in 1920, none of them home runs, so this was an unusually powerful day for the third baseman. He was a bit of an iron man, leading the league in at bats four times in his career.

Wilbur Cooper of the Pirates takes home best pitched game of the day. It’s an unusual situation, as he takes the loss despite his high game score. He allowed two unearned runs on four hits and no walks, striking out two. Twice in the bottom of the fourth inning, rookie shortstop Pie Traynor made throwing errors that wind up costing the Pirates the game.

George Sisler of the Browns sets the single season mark for hits as he posts a two for four day to raise his league leading BA to .407. The two hits give him 249 on the season, one ahead to Ty Cobb‘s 1911 record. Speaker goes two for five in the game to stay at .386. The batting race is over, and now we’ll see if Sisler can stay above .400.

The Yankees and White Sox are idle. The Indians win gives them a one-game lead in the AL, with a two-game lead in the loss column. The Yankees are three games back, but the best they can do is clinch a tie. The Indians magic number is down to four. Jim Bagby of the Indians picks up his 30th win of the season.

On the sports page, the AL Pennant is conceded to Cleveland. The Dodgers and Indians already started discussing the series. It seems that back then a coin toss determined which team would get the extra game at home. The Indians won the toss, but elected to play the middle four game of the best of nine in Cleveland. The Indians wanted more time to erect extra seating. It is also agreed that Joe Sewell, who replace Ray Chapman on the Indians roster following Chapman’s death, would be allowed to play. Sewell joined the Indians after the deadline for post-season play. The page lists all the players on both teams eligible for the series.

September 15, 2020

This Date in 1920

All six scheduled game play to completion on September 15, 1920, including a doubleheader between the Pirates and the Braves in Boston. The Dodgers beat the Cubs 1-0 for the low scoring game of the day. At the high end, the Browns drub the Red Sox 18-5 in St. Louis.

Two hitters post Baseball Musings Batter Game Scores of 76 to tie for best offensive game of the day. Walter Holke of the Braves goes three for three with a double, triple, and walk in the second game of the Braves doubleheader. Boston wins the game 4-1 to earn a split with the Pirates. Tris Speaker of the Indians posts a four for five day with a double and a walk to help the Indians beat the Athletics 14-0.

Right behind them is George Sisler of the Browns who posts a three for four day with a double and two walks. That leaves the AL batting race in Sisler’s control. He raises his batting average to .398, while Speaker closes the gap a bit, now at .393.

On the defensive side, Jim Bagby of the Indians takes home best pitched game of the day. He throws a three-hit shutout, allowing one walk and striking out two. Bagby wins his 28th game of the season, which leads the majors. He also leads in complete games with 27 and innings pitched with 299 2/3. He is not in the top five in any of the three-true outcome categories, nor ERA.

The sports page points out a three excellent outfield plays on the day. The Reds beat the Phillies 3-2, thanks to Cincinnati leftfielder Pat Duncan twice robbing Phillies second baseman Johnny Rawlings of home runs. Tommy Griffith saves the Dodgers game with a catch of a fly ball that looked like it was going for a triple. It was in the ninth inning with one out.

With the Yankees off, the Indians and White Sox both gain 1/2 game on New York. The Yankees lead by one game over Cleveland and 2 1/2 games over the White Sox.

The Dodgers maintain their five-game lead over the Reds, with the idle Giants falling 5 1/2 games back. Brooklyn’s magic number drops to twelve.

September 1, 2020

This Date in 1920

The majors saw action in seven of eight scheduled games on September 1, 1920, including one doubleheader. The Yankees beat the Browns 2-0 for the low scoring game of the day. The Athletics pounded the Tigers 11-4 in game two of their doubleheader for the sweep.

For the second day in a row, Joe Dugan of the Athletics wins best offensive game of the day for his performance in that game two. Dugan collects four hits in two at bats, including two doubles. He drove in two runs and scored three. His two day totals stand at nine hits in sixteen at bats, six runs scored, three doubles and four RBI. He struck out once and stole a base.

Carl Mays of the Yankees earns the shutout in the victory against the Browns. Mays allows just four hits and one walk, striking out two batters. I suspect this game put to rest any idea that Mays would not be able to take the mound after his pitch killed Ray Chapman. Mays wins his 21st game, moving into second place behind Jim Baby of Cleveland with 25 wins. Wilbur Cooper of the Pirates also wins his 21st game, as Pittsburgh defeats New York 4-3. He stands second in the NL.

Tris Speaker of the Indians posts a two for five day to raise his batting average to .396. That breaks the tie with George Sisler of the Browns, who goes one for four and drops to .394.

The Indians beat the Senators 9-5 in Speaker’s game to take first place in the AL pennant race. The Red Sox sweep the series from the White Sox with a 6-2, dropping Chicago into second place, 1/2 game back. The Yankees are also 1/2 game back, but are in third place with a lower winning percentage due to one more loss than Chicago.

Brooklyn gets rained out in St. Louis, so the Reds gain 1/2 a game as they defeat the Braves 6-2 in Cincinnati. The Pirates win over the Giants drops New York to 2 1/2 games back, while the Pirates remain in fourth place, now 4 1/2 games back.

August 3, 2020

This Date in 1920

The major leagues saw all eight scheduled games played on August 3, 1920. It was a bit of an all or nothing day as four games generated no more than five runs, three of those ending in 3-1 scores. The other four games generated at least twelve runs, with two fifteen run contests as the high scoring games of the day.

Ross Youngs of the Giants takes home best offensive game of the day honors as he helps down the Reds 11-1. Youngs posts a three for four day with a walk, a triple and a home run. This is Youngs’s second time recording best game of the day, and the third time he was in the running. Each of these great offensive days included triples. Youngs would hit 93 triples in a ten year career, breaking double digits five times. He is on a hot streak batting .476/.535/.651 in his last 16 games.

Red Farber of the White Sox pitches the best game of the day according to game scores, beating out Herb Pennock of the Red Sox 74-73. Farber, in a 3-1 win against the Yankees, allows five hits but also walked five batters. He struck out six. Pennock, in a 3-1 win against the Tigers, allowed six hits but did not walk a batter, only striking out two. That actually seems like a better afternoon to me. Farber, however, faced a much tougher opponent. Three of his walks were to Babe Ruth, one intentional, and that strategy may have been imposed on him. So Farber will indeed take home best pitched game of the day honors.

Jim Bagby of the Indians wins his twenty second game of the season as Cleveland beats Washington 10-5. He leads the AL and the majors in that category.

Tris Speaker of the Indians goes on for three in that game to reduce his batting average to .418. George Sisler of the Browns takes advantage of the drop to close the gap a bit, his three for four day raising his batting average to .402.

The Indians win coupled with the White Sox beating the Yankees gives Cleveland a four game lead for the AL pennant. The Yankees sit in second, but they are six games down in the loss column. The White Sox are now in spitting distance of second place, 5 1/2 games out of first.

In the NL, the Dodgers beat the Cardinals 11-4. Coupled with the Giants win over the Reds, the Dodgers hold a 2 1/2 game lead for the league title. The Giants remain five games back as the three teams wind up evenly spaced.

July 24, 2020

This Date in 1920

The majors see all eight scheduled games played on July 24, 1920, but only seven produce a decision. The Browns at the Senators ends after five innings in a 1-1 tie due to rain. Of the completed contests, the Tigers defeat the Athletics in Philadelphia 5-0 for the low score. The Cardinals host the Braves with the home team winning 7-6 in ten innings for the high scoring game of the day.

Happy Felsch of the White Sox and Pickles Dillhoefer of the Cardinals both post Baseball Muisngs game scores of 74 for best offensive game of the day honors. Felsch posts a three for five day with a double, home run, and four RBI to help Chicago beat Boston 7-4. Dillhoefer posts a four for five day with a triple in the Cardinals win.

Dillhoefer, a catcher, hit poorly in a very short career. The 1920 season would prove to be his best at the plate, slashing .263/.304/.326 at seasonal age 26. His SABR bio mentions this game as the best of his career, his lead-off triple in the tenth setting up the winning run. He died a few weeks after getting married in 1922 from complications due to typhoid fever.

On the pitching side, Jim Bagby of the Indians and Howard Ehmke of the Tigers tie with game scores of 75 for best pitched game of the day. Bagby becomes the first twenty game winner in the majors as he goes all eleven innings in the 4-2 win over the Yankees. He allows two runs on two solo home runs, a total of six hits, and five walks. He only strikes out three. Ehmke records a shutout on seven hits and two walks, striking out four.

The day ends with Tris Speaker of the Indians as the only .400 hitter in baseball. Speaker posts a two for five day to drop to .418. Joe Jackson goes one for four to drop to .399.

The Indians win prevents them from being swept by the Yankees. Cleveland moves back into first place by percentage points, once again two games up in the loss column. The White Sox also gain on the Yankees, and sit four games out in third place. All three teams are playing above .600 ball.

In the NL, the Reds beat the Giants 5-3 and the Pirates beat the Dodgers 5-1. Cincinnati gains on first place Brooklyn, cutting the Dodgers lead to two games. Pittsburgh sits six games back in third place.

July 20, 2020

This Date in 1920

All nine scheduled games are played to completion on July 20, 1920, including two doubleheaders. The Tigers beat the Senators in game two of their twin bill 2-1 for the low scoring game of the day. Detroit sweeps the pair after a 7-6, fifteen inning win in game one. The high scoring game came in Boston, where the Indians defeated the Red Sox 9-8 in eleven innings. Jim Bagby, who won his eighteenth game of the season the previous day in a start, blows a save in this game, but hangs on for his nineteenth win of the season.

Ross Youngs of the Giants takes home best offensive game of the day honors in New York’s 5-2 win over Pittsburgh. Youngs collected four hits in four plate appearances, including a triple to raise his batting average to .304 and his OBP to .389. Youngs was only a two-true outcomes player. As you can see on the leader boards, he is among the NL top five in walks and strikeouts, but not home runs.

On the pitching side, Howard Ehmke of the Tigers gets the win in the above mentioned game two for best pitched game of the day. Ehmke gives up one earned run on five hits and one walk, striking out three for a game score of 75. Ehmke made this start on two days rest, after pitching an excellent game in game two of the doubleheader, also at Washington, on July 17.

Tris Speaker of the Indians goes two for three to raise his league leading batting average to .419. George Sisler of the Browns goes two for three with a home run to raise his BA to .404 and keep his distance with Speaker. The home run came in the eighth inning and broke a 4-4 tie as the Browns beat the Athletics. Joe Jackson of the White Sox goes two for seven in the double header against the Yankees, dropping him below .400 at .399.

In the news of the day, the Pirates purchased a minor league player described only as “shortstop Traynor.” It is reported that the Pirates paid Portsmouth, of the Virginia League, $10,000 and a pitcher. It set a record for the purchase of a Virginia League player. The new Pirates shortstop was none other than future Hall of Famer Pie Traynor. The news article reports that Traynor was 19 years old, but Baseball Reference has his seasonal age in 1920 at 21. Traynor would play a total of 24 games in 1920 and 1921, before becoming a full time player in 1923.

The Indians extends their lead a half game on the Yankees and the White Sox, as the second and third place teams split their doubleheader. Cleveland now leads the AL by two games over the Yankees and six over the White Sox.

In the NL, Brooklyn and Cincinnati finish their five game series in the World Champions home on the Ohio. The Dodgers win 3-2 and take three of the five games. That gives Brooklyn a three game lead for the pennant.

July 19, 2020

This Date in 1920

The major leagues see eight of ten scheduled games played on July 19, 1920, as two doubleheaders make up for two games postponed by rain. Two games come in with the low run total of the day as the Cubs beat the Braves 5-0 in Chicago, while the Cardinals take twelve innings to beat the Phillies 3-2 in St. Louis. At the high end, the Indians take game one of their doubleheader in Boston 10-6. They drop the night cap to the Red Sox 5-4 in ten innings.

The momentous story of the day takes place at the Polo grounds in a double header split between the Yankees and the White Sox. New York wins game one 8-2, while the White Sox take game two by a score of 8-5. Few New York fans wound up caring about the loss, however.

Babe Ruth takes home best offensive game of the day in the night cap. He hits two home runs off Dickey Kerr, becoming the first major league player to hit 30 home runs in a season. His clout in the fourth inning breaks the record of 29 homers Ruth set the previous season, and the second one put the icing on the cake.

This was front page news.* There were 26,000 people at the game. There was no television or radio, so the story needs to paint a picture of the event. Kerr walked Ruth in the first time they faced each other. Ruth came to bat again in the fourth inning.

Ruth came to bat in the fourth following Pipp, the Yankee first baseman. He slouched up, swinging an extra bat or two. Pipp had sent a hit into left field and the Yankees were behind by one run. This time Kerr shot a ball within reach of Ruth and the Colossus of Swat swung.

At the crack of the bat against the ball the watchers sprang to their feet. There usually is no doubt when Ruth hits a home run, and there was no doubt about it this time. The ball traveled high toward the right field bleachers and struck a few tiers back from the edge.

Ruth paused just an instant to trace the flight of the ball, then he started to trot in a leisurely manner around the bases. His boyish face was illuminated by a broad grin, which he still wore when he crossed the home plate behind Wally Pipp.

The stands were packed with hysterical beings screaming and waving hats.

New York Tribune

This is an important turning point for the major league game. After years of no 30 home run seasons, the next ninety nine trips around the sun would produce a thirty home run season in all but one year, 1945. It would take World War II to drain the majors of enough talent to prevent that level from being reach by a hitter.

The number of 30 home run hitters in a season grew with the number of teams. During the sixteen team era, 1929 and 1930 produced a record ten players with 30 home runs. During the twenty team era (1961**-1968) two seasons produced fifteen players reaching that level, 1964 and 1965. In the 24 team era (1969-1976), the 1970 season produced 19 such seasons. The 26 team era (1977-1992) saw 28 players reach that level in 1987. The 28 team era (1993-1997) produced 40 players for the first time, with 43 hitters at 30 home runs in 1996. With 30 teams, that mark was topped in 1999 (45), 2000 (47) and finally in 2019 with 58 players reaching that level. With only 60 games to play in 2020, we likely will see just the second season since Ruth broke the barrier without a 30 home run hitter.

Note the article on Ruth also contains a bit of a foreshadowing of the upcoming White Sox scandal. The article mentions that Kerr saved the White Sox from “an utter rout” in the previous World Series. See the July 12 review for a discussion of the short but eventful career of Kerr.

In addition, the record home run made Ruth extremely wealthy. A $100,000 movie contract was tied to his breaking the record, and Ruth collected. That would be worth about $1.3 million today.

The best pitched game of the day goes to Bill Sherdel of the Cardinals. He goes the distance in the twelve inning win, allowing nine hits and two earned runs. He shows great control as he does not walk a batter while recording five strikeouts. His game score of 81 beats out Hippo Vaughn‘s six-hit, two-walk shutout for the Cubs.

Sherdel mostly relieved in the early part of his career. He appeared in 199 games in the first five seasons of his career, making 73 starts in that time. Overall, he posted a very solid 27.7 rWAR in his time in the majors, his best year coming in 1925 when he led the NL in winning percentage at .714, going 15-6 with a 3.11 ERA, good for 5.4 rWAR. His control continued to be his strength, walking 2.2 batters per nine inning for his career. From the description in his biography, he was a Tommy John lefty; he didn’t throw hard and he allowed his defense to do most of the work.

Note that Jim Bagby of the Indians wins his eighteenth game of the season in the victory over the Red Sox. Bagby leads the AL and the majors in wins. Bagby also shows up on the leader boards, in games pitched, games started, complete games, and innings pitched.

Tris Speaker of the Indians goes four for eight in the Indians doubleheader to raise his batting average to .417. George Sisler of the Browns goes 1 for 4 to drop to .402 as Speaker takes control of the AL batting race. Sisler is now begin challenged by Joe Jackson, who also goes four for eight and is hitting .401.

With the Indians, Yankees, and White Sox all splitting doubleheaders, the AL standings do not change. Cleveland remains in first place, 1 1/2 games ahead of the Yankees (and three up in the loss column). The White Sox trail first place by 5 1/2 games.

The Reds beat the Dodgers 5-4 as their NL showdown series continues, and Brooklyn’s lead in the NL is cut to two games. The Reds walk off in the bottom of the ninth on an error. Jake Daubert doubled to start the inning. Ed Roush then bunted, and is credited with a hit. Dodgers pitcher Al Mamaux, pitching in relief, throw the bunted ball away for an error, and Daubert scores from third. The Pirates sit seven games back in third place.

*Note that the America’s Cup races led the front page news for the last week, getting the right-hand column placement. Ruth’s record comes at the bottom of the page.

**18 teams in 1961

June 15, 2020

This Date in 1920

The majors saw seven of eight scheduled games played on June 15, 1920. Runs would be plentiful as this turns out to be the fourth highest scoring day of the season in terms of runs per game (minimum six games played), with six of the seven games topping ten runs total. The Tigers beat the Athletics 3-2 for the lone low scoring game, Detroit sweeping the series. The Tigers started the season with a long losing streak, but have now passed the Athletics and sit in seventh place. The Browns beat the Red Sox 12-8 in a slugfest in St. Louis, the Browns also sweeping the series.

Two batter produced Baseball Musings Game Scores of 74 to tie for best offensive game of the day. High Pockets Kelly of the Giants posted a three for four day with a home run and four RBI. The Cardinal win the game, however, 8-7. In the game, Rogers Hornsby of the Cardinals left after being hit in the head by a pitch. It was bad enough that the spectators thought he would be sidelined a while, but it turned out to be a cut above the ear. Hornsby’s name appeared all over the NL leader boards at the time.

Joe Jackson of the White Sox shared the offensive honor with a three for five day, hitting a double and a home run. He also drove in four runs. Chicago beats Washington 9-5. Jackson is among the AL leaders in hits, doubles, triples and RBI.

Two pitchers tied with games scores of 68 for best pitched game of the day. Dutch Leonard of the Tigers and Jim Bagby of the Indians produced identical lines, nine innings, seven hits, two earned runs, two walks, and five strike outs, the Indians drubbing the Yankees 10-2. Leonard starred with the Red Sox the in the teens, averaging 5.5 rWAR from 1913-1917. The 1920 season would be his first with a high ERA, but the game changed and he still pitched decently relative to the league. He would only see action in three more seasons, however.

Bagby’s win pushed his record to 12-2, and he would go on to win 31 games for the pennant winning Indians. This win put him on top of the AL with that total. This would be his last great season as Bagby averaged 5.8 WAR from 1916 through 1920.

In the unusual win of the day, the Pirates beat the Phillies 7-6 in ten innings. The Pirates scored the winning run in the top of the tenth inning when a walk, a ground out, and a single put Pirates Possum Whitted on third and Charlie Grimm on first. The two then executed a double steal to push home the winning run.