The Indians host the Dodgers for game five of the World Series on October 10, 1920. Hyperbole filled the sports writing of the time, but the opening paragraph of the page one game story gets it just right:
In the most spectacular game ever staged in a world’s series, the Brooklyn Dodgers were overwhelmed by the Cleveland Indians in this city to-day by the score of 8 to 1. Everything that could be crowded into a single game was there. For the first time in the history of the game there was a home run with the bases filled and a triple play unassisted.
New York Tribune
The news story actually misses another record set in the game. Cleveland starting pitcher Jim Bagby homered. In the fourth inning:
Doc Johnston shot a hit off Grimes’s knee into center field. He flitted to second on a passed ball. With Sewell out, Grimes meditated for a few moments and concluded to pass O’Neill for Sergeant Jim Bagby. The multitude protested with raucous voices. Grimes had plenty of time to repent this picking of batters.
Sergeant Jim Bagby lifted the pill right over into the newly constructed bleachers in right center field. It was not much of a blow, but it went for a home run, and a home run is a home run. The blow brought over three more runs for the Cleveland Indians, and Burleigh Grimes, with his tow head bowed on his chest, shuffled to the dugout.
New York Tribune
With that blow, Bagby hit the first World Series home run by a pitcher.
The grand slam in the first inning had a great setup. Charlie Jamieson, leading off, singled off the leg of the first baseman. Bill Wambsganss, “after tapping more fouls than he has consonants in his name,” hit a clean single between third and short. Tris Speaker, the number three hitter and one of the best best batters in the game that year, player-manager of the Indians , decided to sacrifice. Burleigh Grimes slipped trying to field the ball, and the play went for a single to load the bases. Up comes Elmer Smith:
Elmer took two hearty and husky swings on nothing. Then it came — for the first time in a world’s series — a home run with the bases filled. It was a straight ball and just where Elmer wanted it. Bob Shawkey, during the late lamented American League series, gave Elmer that kind of ball here and Elmer mussed up the adjacent scenery with it. To-day he lifted the pill over the right field fence onto a roof crowded with local bugs and the bases were cleared for four runs.
New York Tribune
Smith also tripled and singled in the game, by far the best offensive game of the day.
The triple play was what you might expect. In the top of the fifth inning, the Dodgers used two singles to put runners on first and second:
Mitchell, the left-hander, slashed a hard one at Wambsganss. It sounded like a hit and it looked like a hit; everybody started to travel. Wamby made a desperate stab and held the ball. A cool person is this man of many consonants. He stepped over a pace, doubling Kilduff. In the mean time Miller continued to flounder toward second. Wamby reached out and tagged him.
New York Tribune
Note that even though Jim Bagby allowed just one run for the complete game victory, he didn’t pitch that well. He allowed 13 hits to the Dodgers, while Cleveland collected 12. (The Indians did walk four times, while the Dodgers did not draw a base on balls.) The Dodgers, however, kept losing base runners. In addition to the two on the triple play, Cleveland turned three double plays and threw out a runner at the plate. Brooklyn centerfielder Hi Myers attempted two steals and was caught twice. That’s eight runners taken off base.
The Indians now hold a 3-2 lead in the series, and if they sweep at home, the best of nine match will be over.